2014-09-05, 12:45 PM
y0y0y0y0shi0 Wrote:I'm not following Verrkol's logic/reasoning here. Elaborate?
Sorry, I haven't been explaining myself very well here.
I'm trying to say that Shidoshi set himself up with a sort of multi-threaded Catch-22. We're forced to either lynch him blind and risk losing our only doctor or reveal another powerful role like doctor or cop to prove/disprove his identity. Even if someone confirmed his identity, he's useless half the time and not worth saving by any other powerful abilities.
So we can either lynch him as a suspected mafioso and hope that no other Maester Aemon claimed because they wanted to remain hidden or let him live for a night. If we chose not to lynch him, it proves nothing. He is powerless tonight so the mafia could leave him alive and then turn our suspicions on him tomorrow for a lynch or simply kill a somewhat powerful town member and call it a win.
I can't see a good way forward in this situation for the town unless Niernen's theory is correct and that's a crap shoot at best at this point.
On the subject of even night healers, maybe Melisandre can give the breath of life to someone? She's the only possibility I can think of and the extreme effort of reviving someone might explain an even night limitation.