Holypie Wrote:I agree, it's pretty strange, but what else can we really do at this point?
oh yeah I forgot to vote [vote] LuvDWayULie
So I've already reviewed Day1/2. Kyrastri and MasPan spent a lot of time those two days trying to get Luv lynched and it was avoided by such a narrow margin on Day 1 that I'm inclined to believe he is not mafia. HOWEVER, Kyrastri claimed to have used sleep powder ("spore") on Night 2 against Luv and after Luv announced his role PM.
LuvDWayULie Wrote:Meta, before I could even choose a target, tiny particles floated around me and I fell asleep. So, at the end, I didn't target anyone. Wasn't really planning to target.
Interestingly, no one has ever claimed the ability to use Sleep Powder and Kyrastri didn't have it. It could have been Olsi's Metronome, except he was already dead.
So from this small clue, we're left with 3 scenarios.
1. Kyrastri and Luv are both mafia and made the whole thing up with Luv choosing not to use his power that night for some reason.
2. Kyrastri was covering for another mafia member under the guise of his fake Parasect claim. This means either TheBirds or Cakes is mafia since all other abilities have been confirmed by multiple parties.
3. Same as above but someone with a confirmed ability has a second one which has largely remained hidden. I don't think there are any confirmed claimed pokemon that can learn Sleep Powder.
EDIT: Scenario 4 would be that Olsi was able to use his Metronome before he died that night. We do know that xBTAx was able to use Mirror Move before his death, but we have no idea what priority non-protection moves get for timing. Just based on knowing the my Watergun occurs AFTER the mafia kill, I find this unlikely.
IMO, if Luv is innocent there should be an electric weak pokemon on the mafia side because otherwise he could only get "super effective" kills on town allies which doesn't seem likely to me. This points towards TheBirds, but Cakes type is entirely unconfirmed.
As much as I hate to say it, I think lynching Luv is the town's best move even if he's innocent because it will give us a lot of information.
It's for the good of the town buddy.