Gen I Pokemon Mafia - Mafia Wins

A mafia doctor makes no sense, since the town rarely has kill abilities unless there's a revenge killer (which I doubt would exist here). It's also a one shot which doesn't really make a mafia doctor have much point (and also negates the severity of the revenge kill).

You have a point there, but if it's not too much to ask why do you doubt that a revenge killer would exist here? I'm simply curious, since I did see it in previous games on SP but that's getting a bit too meta-gamey for something that doesn't really matter right now.

Luv is too suspicious to me with the way he has acted and his ability and I havent seen much of a defense about his innocence. Of course we have plenty of time to debate things.

Wait what? Maybe I haven't read it right but isn't the fact that Verr was defending Luv reason for you to be calling them out to be lynched? That doesn't make any sense to me ._. While Verr's reason for defending Luv is sketchy, I don't understand the fixation at all, like TheBirds said.

!?!?!!? Luv's power doesn't guarantee that his target will be blocked because there's only a 25% chance of paralysis interrupting the target's action. This means that if he hits a townie they're at a disadvantage over time, and if he hits a mafioso there's no guarantee that the mafioso's action will be stopped. There isn't a difference, but what I'm saying is that his power is unreliable when we need it and harmful when we don't.

I didn't say anything about a mafia doctor, I have absolutely no idea where that idea came from.

Ohh wait, did you think I meant that there's an ability that can prevent people from being roleblocked? I was saying that Luv's weird roleblock (also your being dazed) might suggest the presence of a legitimate roleblocker who has a 100% chance of stopping someone's action for a single night.

Yeah sorry, bad wording is bad.

Oh god, my bad! I didn't pick up that you were talking about Luv's roleblocking. In that case, definitely; Luv should be laying off doing anything tonight, in exchange for us not lynching him. The only problem I'd have with my suggestion is that it leaves a lot of uncertainty, in that anyone can claim that they were attacked by Luv and he'd be unable to defend himself. (I remember Hypermug addressed this) But that'd occur whether or not he actually attacked someone in the first place, so maybe we're better off letting him decide.

Lastly, meowmixx's behavior is fishy to me. The continued use of weird posts, and the interest in Kyrastri's ability even though it was blocked anyway.

I don't remember meow being interested in my ability, moreso who I was, where at this point if it's not obvious enough shame on you! Someone else asked what I did. And I'd rethink her motives, Hyper.

Hypermug; i only have a natural curiosity. am i the only one who is interested in the unown (LOL)?

... -clap-

what time of the day is it? theory o clock!

Not really. This time it's literally a list of possibilities.

 The HyperCakes fiasco

In which Hyper is Mafia, and Cakes is Town
- Implies that the role forcer is more likely to be town because mafia-targeting-mafia is unlikely
- Note that if the role forcer is mafia, then it implies that Hyper has a protect-type skill that can self target because there are no reasons that I can think of that a mafioso would target one of their own people.
+ Motives would be to check out Pokemon abilities and to try and target as many people as possible, and to potentially test out mafia abilities. This would mean that Night 1 was testing waters, and with results, we may have a hell of a night 2 ahead of us.

- I don't really know what cakes's done to make himself a target, but now that we've found out that Cakes doesn't immediately act with his ability the mafia is pretty likely to target someone else. On the other hand, if what Cakes' ability is what I think it is that might not be the case ._.

In which Hyper is Town, and Cakes is Mafia
- Implies role forcer has no idea wtp they are doing (town) and are trying to find out as much about their skills as possible
+ Note that if the role forcer is mafia, it indicates that they didn't know that it was a role forcer and assumed it was an ability stealer. It also implies that Cakes has a move that is worth duplicating for rather than trying to choose person with the most tasty breadcrumbs.

- Hyper being town wouldn't really confirm anything, but it's more likely that Hyper is town with this scenario.

In which both Cakes and Hyper are mafia
- no, pineapple this who is that stupid- ugh fine
- Implies role forcer is very likely town
+ if the role forcer is mafia, it would indicate that they wanted to duplicate a skill to apply it to Hyper. I highly doubt this because it's a BIG jump in logic on their behalf.

In which both Cakes and Hyper are Town
- Implies clueless town role forcer (in which case I would encourage you to stop) or evil mafioso role forcer (in which case I would encourage you to admit yourself so we can lynch you)

Sorry I'm getting really tired... If I need to correct anything I will do it tomorrow!