2014-08-04, 10:05 PM
It is hard to tell with Luv if he is mafia or not. I find it strange he chose to roleclaim a pokemon which would probably be guaranteed in a Gen 1 pokemon mafia. There may be a counterclaim, but to pick Pikachu is a big gamble. Whether he is mafia or not is a different story. We have had town roleblockers (actually I was the prostitute, but it was the same thing); but they are a gamble since they can accidentally stop the town. On the other hand, I am also not too much in favor of subs, because two people often play differently, but since it is being done early it isn't too bad.
Personally after reading Holypie's comment I am going to [vote]Shidoshi. Even if Luv is bait for the mafia kill, we at least protect the doctor and detective for a Night rather than leaving it to chance. Even if Luv doesn't dies from the mafia, they will more than likely use him as bait, and we can always check him tonight or later. At leave by voting for Shidoshi we can (hopefully) get a relatively harmless lynch.
Personally after reading Holypie's comment I am going to [vote]Shidoshi. Even if Luv is bait for the mafia kill, we at least protect the doctor and detective for a Night rather than leaving it to chance. Even if Luv doesn't dies from the mafia, they will more than likely use him as bait, and we can always check him tonight or later. At leave by voting for Shidoshi we can (hopefully) get a relatively harmless lynch.