2014-07-14, 01:48 AM
I seriously need to start the habit of taking notes. I'll start from this post onwards, I guess.
Thank you Kyra, for your compliment.
It's hard to assume someone with good logic and sizeable posts isn't scum, and all of you should not forget that. I believe Kyra is townie more from her ability than her prowess in logic. As beautiful as it was, Kyra just pointed out the possibilities of what could happened, something anyone could do if throwing the laziness aside. Besides, it would made a lot more sense if Mafia had manipulative night powers, such as roleblock. I don't believe Chaz is mafia because compulsive roles are almost always town and that would be too strange a gambit to throw off.
About Chaz, unless the Doctor made a save last night, he's propably a manipulative role as well, which would be detrimental to the town unless he had a very specific use for it. Basically Chaz would be detrimental now and very useful late game, that is, if you do buy my logic.
About the chances of there being a vengeful on the game, it wouldn't make sense in a role madness game. The point to this game is having multiple night powers, all affecting each other.
Hmm. Maybe that was Shidoshi's function after all: provide the town something to "clean out" whatever infected our information, such as incorrect information from cops, which could come from either insanity, Godfather, tailoring, etc; or maybe even detect a redirector or - Phas forbid - a bus driver.
...
I wouldn't be surprised at all if there was a bus driver. It would make sense. Maybe that's Chaz role? Compulsive bus driver? Or compulsive redirector. Or maybe the mafia have them, I don't know, ugh. I think that's good thinking material, don't you, [MENTION=10411]Kyrastri[/MENTION];?
I also think MasPan meant himself as the cat. He did change avatars to a cat. A very famous cat, may I add.
By the way, maybe you are overthinking Kyra's ability. At least, to me it seems pretty obvious. Yesterday, he had double vote. He did not need to recieve a PM about this, it would just be accounted when BTA made his Tally and that's it. Today, he could still vote, but it wouldn't be accounted, so it's no big deal. Since the mods around here do not actually post the official vote tally, we can't REALLY confirm it, but still.
And why does LuvD strike me as an arsonist?
And sure, Meta's "restriction" is annoying, but Chaotic has suggested from day one some sort of help to him and Meta didn't address that at all.
Anyway, what else could I say? Hmm...
Using loose parameters, I'd say MasPan, Kyra and Niernen are town and TheBirds is mafia/neutral.
Going a bit deeper and using more deduction, they didn't actually kill a mafia and TheBirds may be just being a lurker townie, even if a doukabaga one.
However, for reasons I've stated before, I believe Chaz and Kyra are townie. LuvD still strikes me as an arsonist, and I never trust anything that goes out Meta's mouth.
___
Edit: From what I caught of MasPan, I'd say he believes in the
However, he's not so sure and he's warning us to not take what he thinks as granted. I could not realize though if that includes voting Chaz or not. He could be either saying he just voted in Chaz to force him to talk and further prove/disprove of MasPan's theory or to simply be careful.
I've wasted one phasdamn hour building up this post, you'd better make good use of it
Now, I'm off to bed.
Thank you Kyra, for your compliment.
It's hard to assume someone with good logic and sizeable posts isn't scum, and all of you should not forget that. I believe Kyra is townie more from her ability than her prowess in logic. As beautiful as it was, Kyra just pointed out the possibilities of what could happened, something anyone could do if throwing the laziness aside. Besides, it would made a lot more sense if Mafia had manipulative night powers, such as roleblock. I don't believe Chaz is mafia because compulsive roles are almost always town and that would be too strange a gambit to throw off.
About Chaz, unless the Doctor made a save last night, he's propably a manipulative role as well, which would be detrimental to the town unless he had a very specific use for it. Basically Chaz would be detrimental now and very useful late game, that is, if you do buy my logic.
About the chances of there being a vengeful on the game, it wouldn't make sense in a role madness game. The point to this game is having multiple night powers, all affecting each other.
Hmm. Maybe that was Shidoshi's function after all: provide the town something to "clean out" whatever infected our information, such as incorrect information from cops, which could come from either insanity, Godfather, tailoring, etc; or maybe even detect a redirector or - Phas forbid - a bus driver.
...
I wouldn't be surprised at all if there was a bus driver. It would make sense. Maybe that's Chaz role? Compulsive bus driver? Or compulsive redirector. Or maybe the mafia have them, I don't know, ugh. I think that's good thinking material, don't you, [MENTION=10411]Kyrastri[/MENTION];?
I also think MasPan meant himself as the cat. He did change avatars to a cat. A very famous cat, may I add.
By the way, maybe you are overthinking Kyra's ability. At least, to me it seems pretty obvious. Yesterday, he had double vote. He did not need to recieve a PM about this, it would just be accounted when BTA made his Tally and that's it. Today, he could still vote, but it wouldn't be accounted, so it's no big deal. Since the mods around here do not actually post the official vote tally, we can't REALLY confirm it, but still.
And why does LuvD strike me as an arsonist?
And sure, Meta's "restriction" is annoying, but Chaotic has suggested from day one some sort of help to him and Meta didn't address that at all.
Anyway, what else could I say? Hmm...
Using loose parameters, I'd say MasPan, Kyra and Niernen are town and TheBirds is mafia/neutral.
Going a bit deeper and using more deduction, they didn't actually kill a mafia and TheBirds may be just being a lurker townie, even if a doukabaga one.
However, for reasons I've stated before, I believe Chaz and Kyra are townie. LuvD still strikes me as an arsonist, and I never trust anything that goes out Meta's mouth.
___
Edit: From what I caught of MasPan, I'd say he believes in the
Kyrastri Wrote:- Niernen is Town, Chaz is Mafia, Town/Neutral/Mafia is perpetrating Included mafia because it could all be a fancy bussing technique. Damn fancy bussing techniques. Town/Neutral could have figured out that Chaz is mafia, but will need to claim in order to verify this so they're in a tight spot, so it's more likely mafia if Chaz is mafia.except that the mafia is using it as some form of reverse psychology to save Chaz's sweet buttocks. Oh look, TheBirds looks even scummier to me now.
However, he's not so sure and he's warning us to not take what he thinks as granted. I could not realize though if that includes voting Chaz or not. He could be either saying he just voted in Chaz to force him to talk and further prove/disprove of MasPan's theory or to simply be careful.
I've wasted one phasdamn hour building up this post, you'd better make good use of it
Now, I'm off to bed.