2014-07-13, 05:20 PM
[MENTION=814]MasPan[/MENTION]; I'm not sure if I'm reading it right, but are you trying to say that [MENTION=5839]Chaz[/MENTION]; would have forced me to vote for him so he would look innocent and I would look scummy? It seems like a possible gamble, but I don't think mafia having a vote altering power would be balanced, because then they could influence people to lynch innocents and kill of townies twice as fast. It would make more sense for a townie or neutral to have a vote altering power, the neutral might have a certain win condition, or the townie could use it to help kill off someone they thought was mafia.
I'll paraphrase my pm as best I can since I can't post it: Ignoring everything that goes on tomorrow, you would vote for Chaz. You don't know why, but it seems to be the correct choice.
Don't know if that really sheds any light, but why would I lie about being forced to vote for Chaz? Most of us had agreed he was not the most scummy, and it really does not seem the best way to protect someone. I understand what you are saying about how someone being forced to vote for Chaz would make him seem more innocent because he becomes a target, but I don't know why someone would single out Chaz or me.
edit: I realize either way I look bad. If I'm lying and you leave him, he could be mafia. If you don't believe my and lynch him, you could kill a possible townie, either way it does not look good for either of us. So take it how you will. Also, has TheBirds posted much?
I'll paraphrase my pm as best I can since I can't post it: Ignoring everything that goes on tomorrow, you would vote for Chaz. You don't know why, but it seems to be the correct choice.
Don't know if that really sheds any light, but why would I lie about being forced to vote for Chaz? Most of us had agreed he was not the most scummy, and it really does not seem the best way to protect someone. I understand what you are saying about how someone being forced to vote for Chaz would make him seem more innocent because he becomes a target, but I don't know why someone would single out Chaz or me.
edit: I realize either way I look bad. If I'm lying and you leave him, he could be mafia. If you don't believe my and lynch him, you could kill a possible townie, either way it does not look good for either of us. So take it how you will. Also, has TheBirds posted much?