Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory

And wtp Polantaris you know me better than this. If I was mafia I would've roleclaimed something by now. But I'm not. I'm a regular old lousy townie.

The pure silence was annoying me. Everything has gone to pomegranate and you still said nothing at all. I'm happy that you have, and I've removed the vote to you. I just feel like an experienced player such as yourself should be participating to some degree but I saw almost nothing from you, especially when that's usually the game you play when you're mafia. With everyone having roleclaimed by Day 3, there wasn't really anything left for you to roleclaim if you wanted to, and you have to admit that that's true at this point.

I'm Shortstem Sue, a Golden Apple with no powers. Honestly, I believe Kyrastri and KhainiWest are mafia.

On Kyrastri:

a) pineapple you guys if 2 REAL cops becomes a thing. That's literally the most overpowered thing ever, unless Maspan is pulling some reverse psychology pomegranate and hoping we only think there's one cop (then PINEAPPLE YOU GOD). There wasn't even two cops in the Mafia game before this. Since Holypie was the cop, then if Kyrastri is cop, then pineapple me.

b) Kyrastri literally always posted investigations after Holypie did. Who the hell does that besides a new-to-mafia player posing as a cop?

c) I"m also willing to bet Kyrastri or someone in the mafia actually thought Meta was the cop, and so was pushed to counterclaim. After all, it's better for the mafia to have a fake cop than to let the sheriff rampage unopposed. Fortunately for them, the other two cop-claimees died, and now for whatever pineappleing reason there are still doubts Kyrastri is mafia.

d) Didn't die yet. If she was a real cop she would've died by now.

On KhainiWest, the world's shittiest doctor:

a) There is NO REASON why you should come out as doctor unless you're about to be lynched. No. Reason. At. All. Unless you're Mafia and want a role to fakeclaim. KhainiWest was always probing around with his constant "YO DOCTOR, YOU SHOULD COME OUT," trying as a Mafia to scare out the Doctor. I'm willing to bet when he figured out there's no Doctor in the game, he might as well roleclaim it unopposed.

b) Literally 0 saves. Only the mafia do this.

c) Didn't die yet. If he was a real doctor with 0 saves he should've died by now.

d) I have no idea what he's talking about, although that's probably just me since I just skimmed his rants.

So here's the reason I removed my vote from Kyrastri: She COULD be a naive cop. A cop that only sees people as innocent. It's a distinct possibility. Granted if true they're completely worthless to us as a cop, but we can't afford to lynch people wrongly.

I'm not so sure she would have died by now, either. On Day 2, three people roleclaimed cop. Meta, the clearly most logical choice, was killed first, because they outted Words as godmother. Regardless of the fact that they were lying or not, it's irrelevant because the mafia didn't know that either. On Day 3, the Mafia murdered Meta, and VerrKol was killed by CJ. I don't think he specifically said it but it makes sense, and I can see the flavor text fitting CJ's role. On Day 4, Holypie was killed by the mafia. That means they've only had the chance to kill 2/3 cops.

The interesting thing is that they didn't kill KhainiWest. It's possible they don't believe his claim either, or expected him to do nothing after the "debate" that day, and realized they could risk leaving him alone. Or they knew that KhainiWest wouldn't protect Holypie, since KhainiWest was so adamantly against Holypie, but they believed Holypie WAS a cop, and knew he was open without another investigation possibly revealing them.

The overall problem with this game is that we have no reveals. We have nothing. Words didn't take any sides what so ever, and no one defended Words. Their reveal meant nothing to us in the long run. Every investigation that has been mentioned, true or not, has mentioned people being innocent. While it sucks, it's also not that implausible. The end result is that we can only go with our own suspicions, which no one believes anyone else and is just a huge finger pointing contest.