Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory

Will give my explanation later as I'm on the phone.

To reply Kyrastri's question, Merry Mac is your other counterpart, Holypie.

I know what I said is baseless. Will edit this post to fit in my explanation.

[EDIT]
Let me start with this first.

>claims doctor
>No one counterclaims
>Blames person for game hosts poorly worded role

In fact you're new to this so I'd be surprised if you knew what a doctor role actually did. It sounds like, based on your flimsy reasoning, you want to get me lynched so you can use your mafia power on one of the cops. I'm positive you're mafia now, you're inexperienced just like the mafia members.

Oh wow, I knew you're gonna say this over and over again. Me being a mafia? I know quite a few people are getting suspicious of me too, and I'm not going to defend myself, as I said earlier.

And no, I do know what does a doctor do. Its name already said by itself: To protect a player from being killed at night. My reasoning is flimsy, but unlike you, I don't keep asking who's the doctor and then suddenly claim to be a doctor.

Plus, what makes me even sure that you're the mafia member is when you keep accusing me of being one, when I'm not. You obviously know who are the mafias. and I'm one of the most suspected mafia members, so you decided to blame it all on me.

Okay, yeah, shooting that Olsi was innocent straight off was pretty pineappleing stupid of me. I didn't even consider to do that.



Personally, I don't think he, or anyone else should be attributing scummy behaviour for new player syndrome. It's been several days, people. It doesn't take that long to read a few pages on mafiascum.

I don't think Khaini should be crucified for giving suspicions, especially given the fact that he didn't back most of those up with a vote (he has already given his justification against Holypie) since we were all practically encouraging one another to voice opinions. He did it crudely at first, but I think he has a point for now.

Really? I would, though not to the obvious extent that Khaini went (which naturally completely flew over my head in a glorious shower of fireworks and wooshing noises). It would focus attention away from you, especially when telling the doctor to keep quiet. What I don't understand is why he was telling the doctor to come forward, not because I think he's mafia, but because the doctor would be at a disadvantage (to me at least) with their identity known to the mafia.



Why would they openly waste their lynch immunity, though? I'm curious to hear what you've got to say

Back up a little bit. I don't understand what you're saying.

Why would you have killed Khaini in the first few days? How does this bring you to him now?

He has every right to criticise anyone, barring his use of language. There were no rules that we couldn't criticise past behaviour. Also, what leads you to believe that he isn't the doctor? Aside from my previous mention of him trying to out the doctor then claiming, I don't see what else would strike him as suss.



Buddy, I'm just as baffled as you are D: I never expected full alignment information, but I'm honestly gonna work with and report whatever I get.

Um... mind telling us who is who? I know Goodwife is LuvD, Sour was Verrkol and Godmother was Words (and gilly was me ofc c but who are the rest?

My Role PM only alludes to investigating "clues" to their "identity". You could infer that I'd be able to find more information if they used/didn't use a night action, so if that's the case;

If Olsi used a night action, ChaoticCJ did not.
If Olsi did not use a night action, ChaoticCJ did, which might allude to mafia-like behaviour (I believe [Kill] would count as a night action for mafia)

EDIT


Clearly it means we [vote] maspan, amirite :p



Goddamn movie knowledge ]:

There's quite a number of Golden Delicious apples, myself included :3

Clearly now the attention has been focused on me. And, my purpose of accusing Khaini of being the mafia does not push the attention away from me, but instead I'm suspected as one now. Why am I doing this if I'm the mafia? I would have gone with the majority and voted for TheBirds, which I clearly did not do. Yes, you might say that I'm voting a allegedly claimed doctor, but as I said earlier, I don't believe he is one but he is the mafia himself.

I would've killed Khaini in the first few days because iirc (Sorry if I'm wrong), like me, Khaini posted passive stuffs and was not actively contributing to the Town (I may be wrong, and you can blame me for this. But because of the time constraint, I do not have enough time to double-check). His hysterical posts further escalated the suspicions. About "this brings to you now", disregard it, as I was using figurative speech.

About Khaini criticizing everyone, I believe he can do so, but to me, his critique does not seem to help the Town in finding the mafia. I think he is just going around in circles, blaming everyone for being incompetent in finding out the mafia, and not going in his way. This does not look very Town-ish to me. With faol's post collecting Khaini's posts where Khaini asked who's the doctor, then suggested what the doctor should do, and then claimed that he himself is a doctor, I am even more sure that Khaini is a potential mafia candidate (Note that I use candidate, not mafia itself, as I may be wrong)

Finally, I do not blame Maspan for his usage of words. Heck, I do not even know if Khaini is really paraphrasing Maspan's words, or just creating his own words.

If I'm wrong about Khaini, I'm sorry. I will not be surprised if I'm lynched today (If not today, then the next day) because I'm one of the only ones (Other than CJ's post about agreeing about my suspicions) to suggest/accuse that Khaini is the mafia, with Khaini counter accused me as one. If I'm dead by tonight, good luck Townies. If I'm alive by tonight, I'll try my best to find the remaining mafias.

P.S. To Khaini, please do not be angry at me after the game. I treat this as merely an intellectual discussion/game, which I will just play for fun