Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory

The point of my entire suggestion, which everyone was pretty much on board for until the last minute, was to spread our search. The purpose of this is because sanity isn't easily verified especially by simply researching the same guy. Neither party did this smart, they didn't withhold information or mislead the other claimed cop to verify if they both got the same information. They revealed "he good apple" followed by "I agree". That provides us nothing, so right now we are sitting pretty with one less person to perpetrate, which is one that POSTS ALL OF THE TIME.

Okay, yeah, shooting that Olsi was innocent straight off was pretty pineappleing stupid of me. I didn't even consider to do that.

Both Khaini and LuvD have made things that can be attributed as either newbness or scum. However, LuvD's majority voting was more clearly newbish and he has been pretty forward saying he's new to the game as well as changing his behavior. Khaini's has been gauging players as lynch targets with weak reasoning and hasn't really come here apologize for anything as new player syndrome.

Personally, I don't think he, or anyone else should be attributing scummy behaviour for new player syndrome. It's been several days, people. It doesn't take that long to read a few pages on mafiascum.

I don't think Khaini should be crucified for giving suspicions, especially given the fact that he didn't back most of those up with a vote (he has already given his justification against Holypie) since we were all practically encouraging one another to voice opinions. He did it crudely at first, but I think he has a point for now.

However, as posts were put onto the thread, and especially faon's, it seems quite clear that Khaini kept asking who's the doctor and suddenly makes a post claiming he is the doctor. I find it strange and odd, as if I were the doctor, I would not ask about who's the doctor (Obviously). Khaini's tone is really worrying me, and I think he could be a potential mafia.

Really? I would, though not to the obvious extent that Khaini went (which naturally completely flew over my head in a glorious shower of fireworks and wooshing noises). It would focus attention away from you, especially when telling the doctor to keep quiet. What I don't understand is why he was telling the doctor to come forward, not because I think he's mafia, but because the doctor would be at a disadvantage (to me at least) with their identity known to the mafia.

- Mafia with 1-shot lynch immunity, which would not be a first on SP.

Why would they openly waste their lynch immunity, though? I'm curious to hear what you've got to say

If I were the mafia, I would have killed you instead in the first few days, which brings me to you now.

Back up a little bit. I don't understand what you're saying.

Why would you have killed Khaini in the first few days? How does this bring you to him now?

I don't think you're the doctor. Even if you are, your powers aren't helping the town when you are just criticizing about everything!

He has every right to criticise anyone, barring his use of language. There were no rules that we couldn't criticise past behaviour. Also, what leads you to believe that he isn't the doctor? Aside from my previous mention of him trying to out the doctor then claiming, I don't see what else would strike him as suss.

What I'm kind of confused about is why the hell does Kyrastri get different information in different nights? First night she gets that CJ is a green apple whoop dee doo, and the next night she gets legitimate alignment information? I don't know about you guys but that's a bit strange. Not necessarily saying that she's suspicious (that's really silly to be a mafia and claim flavour cop against a cop claim) but it's something to note.

Buddy, I'm just as baffled as you are D: I never expected full alignment information, but I'm honestly gonna work with and report whatever I get.

Mealy Mel, Gilded Gilly, Goldy Goodwife, Merry Mac, Sour Sheila, Barney Brewster all has something in common… while Godmother Smith and Johnny Red have something in common. Perhaps it is my paranoid nature, but it seems like a better clue than what we have now.

Um... mind telling us who is who? I know Goodwife is LuvD, Sour was Verrkol and Godmother was Words (and gilly was me ofc c but who are the rest?

Oh, I also keep forgetting to ask. Holypie, and Kyrastri would either of your abilities indicate if someone did something at night? The only reason I am asking is because Kyrastri’s abilities seemed to have changed from one night to the next and I was wondering if it had to do with if a person decides to use an ability at night. The reason I am asking is because if Olsi knew he was going to be targeted, it would be smart to do nothing the night he was investigated. I may be wrong; I am just not sure how either of your abilities works. [I am mostly just curious for the sake of information and statistics-not actually throwing suspicion at you are anything like that.]

My Role PM only alludes to investigating "clues" to their "identity". You could infer that I'd be able to find more information if they used/didn't use a night action, so if that's the case;

If Olsi used a night action, ChaoticCJ did not.
If Olsi did not use a night action, ChaoticCJ did, which might allude to mafia-like behaviour (I believe [Kill] would count as a night action for mafia)

EDIT

This post just enhances the theory that you are, in fact, a potential mafia candidate.

Clearly it means we [vote] maspan, amirite :p

I went with Ruffalo because the actor, who played the Hulk in the avengers is also a doctor, technically, which is what I was stating was a subtext hint to polantaris or whatever. My actual name is Shining Sam and I'm a golden apple, wasn't there another golden one?

Goddamn movie knowledge ]:

There's quite a number of Golden Delicious apples, myself included :3