2014-06-20, 07:00 AM
Well this is interesting. I am still going off of my apple theory, but it led me to this:
Mealy Mel, Gilded Gilly, Goldy Goodwife, Merry Mac, Sour Sheila, Barney Brewster all has something in common… while Godmother Smith and Johnny Red have something in common. Perhaps it is my paranoid nature, but it seems like a better clue than what we have now.
I am still not entirely convinced KhainiWest is the doctor. There are two other player who have hinted toward being the doctor, and with the mess I don't blame them for hiding. The only thing is that KhainiWest seem to be about 75% town, but with a 33% chance of being the doctor. The only thing that keeps me from saying that you are 100% town is that if everyone has been truthful about their name it is possible you are Ruffalo Robin(or Robin Ruffalo). I think it was Niernen(I can’t remember for sure and it’s late) who said something about a Robin and the flavor indicates the same.
Oh, I also keep forgetting to ask. Holypie, and Kyrastri would either of your abilities indicate if someone did something at night? The only reason I am asking is because Kyrastri’s abilities seemed to have changed from one night to the next and I was wondering if it had to do with if a person decides to use an ability at night. The reason I am asking is because if Olsi knew he was going to be targeted, it would be smart to do nothing the night he was investigated. I may be wrong; I am just not sure how either of your abilities works. [I am mostly just curious for the sake of information and statistics-not actually throwing suspicion at you are anything like that.]
I do want to see what people have to say about my names theory before voting...
Mealy Mel, Gilded Gilly, Goldy Goodwife, Merry Mac, Sour Sheila, Barney Brewster all has something in common… while Godmother Smith and Johnny Red have something in common. Perhaps it is my paranoid nature, but it seems like a better clue than what we have now.
I am still not entirely convinced KhainiWest is the doctor. There are two other player who have hinted toward being the doctor, and with the mess I don't blame them for hiding. The only thing is that KhainiWest seem to be about 75% town, but with a 33% chance of being the doctor. The only thing that keeps me from saying that you are 100% town is that if everyone has been truthful about their name it is possible you are Ruffalo Robin(or Robin Ruffalo). I think it was Niernen(I can’t remember for sure and it’s late) who said something about a Robin and the flavor indicates the same.
Oh, I also keep forgetting to ask. Holypie, and Kyrastri would either of your abilities indicate if someone did something at night? The only reason I am asking is because Kyrastri’s abilities seemed to have changed from one night to the next and I was wondering if it had to do with if a person decides to use an ability at night. The reason I am asking is because if Olsi knew he was going to be targeted, it would be smart to do nothing the night he was investigated. I may be wrong; I am just not sure how either of your abilities works. [I am mostly just curious for the sake of information and statistics-not actually throwing suspicion at you are anything like that.]
I do want to see what people have to say about my names theory before voting...