2014-06-19, 02:35 PM
I'm back. (I was Mapling and doing some other stuff. It's 2:24am here).
First of all, I, too, believe that the doctor should not reveal him/herself. It's like committing suicide where the mafia can just kill you (Unless you're sure of the mafia of course). This is what Niernen and Polantaris said, which I agree.
Secondly, I think I should put my theory aside for a while, since the situation has changed. I have initially related KhainiWest's erraticness as a sign of frustration towards the game. However, as posts were put onto the thread, and especially faon's, it seems quite clear that Khaini kept asking who's the doctor and suddenly makes a post claiming he is the doctor. I find it strange and odd, as if I were the doctor, I would not ask about who's the doctor (Obviously). Khaini's tone is really worrying me, and I think he could be a potential mafia.
Thirdly, Shidoshi finally speaks up, which is something good, in my opinion. And I sincerely thank you for explaning your reasons why Holypie is a mafia suspect. But since the situation has changed, I would disregard my theory about one of the cops being a mafia member.
Based on everyone's replies, I believe we have a better chance finding for the mafia member.
[Vote] KhainiWest
[EDIT]
And Holypie, no, I'm not out to get you
I just want to see you and other people's reaction, which is why I'm not pursuing my theory further.
To others, if my post here is unhelpful, I'm sorry. I can't find better words to explain them already, as what I feel is what you all have posted. I'm merely paraphrasing sentences.
First of all, I, too, believe that the doctor should not reveal him/herself. It's like committing suicide where the mafia can just kill you (Unless you're sure of the mafia of course). This is what Niernen and Polantaris said, which I agree.
Secondly, I think I should put my theory aside for a while, since the situation has changed. I have initially related KhainiWest's erraticness as a sign of frustration towards the game. However, as posts were put onto the thread, and especially faon's, it seems quite clear that Khaini kept asking who's the doctor and suddenly makes a post claiming he is the doctor. I find it strange and odd, as if I were the doctor, I would not ask about who's the doctor (Obviously). Khaini's tone is really worrying me, and I think he could be a potential mafia.
Thirdly, Shidoshi finally speaks up, which is something good, in my opinion. And I sincerely thank you for explaning your reasons why Holypie is a mafia suspect. But since the situation has changed, I would disregard my theory about one of the cops being a mafia member.
Based on everyone's replies, I believe we have a better chance finding for the mafia member.
[Vote] KhainiWest
[EDIT]
And Holypie, no, I'm not out to get you
I just want to see you and other people's reaction, which is why I'm not pursuing my theory further. To others, if my post here is unhelpful, I'm sorry. I can't find better words to explain them already, as what I feel is what you all have posted. I'm merely paraphrasing sentences.

