Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory

In fact I find it kind of questionable to begin with that holypie literally disregarded all of my logic just to go with a method to "clarify" something, and waste two townies lives based on that

I'm a little confused here. How is that Holypie's fault? No matter who they investigated, two people were going to die. Two kills were used. One was probably a revenge kill, while the other was the regular mafia kill. I don't understand your logic here at all.

In fact, if anything is the cause of the second death, it's you, because by your own logic and admittance, you're solely responsible for Words' death, and the second kill is most definitely a revenge kill the more that I think about it.

You disregarded my instructions which would have broaden our fog of war. Where are we now mr holypie? Two "cops", a good Olsi, and no f`ucking leads. Oh and to top it all off we have a secondary way for them to kill us off. All because of your paranoia of something that frankly at this point is irrelevant. Do you know why it's irrelevant? Because one of you has a secure lead, which gives a 50% statistical advantage over zero.

You took a risk, no, I convinced you and all you other numb skulls to take down words, and TRUST her, yes, it's a f`ucking her. Now we have no plan, and your juvenile deflecting tactic just really secures the scum level bull sh`it about you. You think I'm leading the town off path? I lead us to the leader of the organization and f`uckking crucified her.

Firstly, we had no evidence to support anything. For all we know, all three of them are bsing us. We know Meta was. Maybe someone else is the cop and they've intentionally hidden themselves to stay far away from this crazy role claim. Your entire "leading us to the boss" was based on a lie. Above that, how do we know you're not getting bussed in? It happened last game, and worked, which makes it all that more likely that the mafia will try again this game. There's no way for us to know, and your stubbornness towards this stance that you're solely responsible for Words' lynch is further supporting a bussing.




That aside, I went over the first ~10 pages of this thread and wrote down nearly everything. I'll be doing the rest later, but based on what I remember combined with the things I wrote down:

Very Suspicious To Me:
ChaoticCJ: Basically gets very angry over a slight paraphrase to his post about waiting to decide what to do. Then, when questioned later, he votes for VerrKol so that he can "force people to choose sides and see what happens," which appears RIDICULOUSLY mafia to me. Then jumps in with 6 minutes left on the clock on Day 1 and votes for Sega to kill him, saying that he had to do it to keep himself alive, but I'm not sure he was going to be lynched because of a tie.

TheBirds: Even more suspicious than ChaoticCJ, because he's posted ONE post that I've seen from my note taking earlier, and I don't remember a single post from him on the posts beyond that. Above that, this single post was completely and utterly useless. My note for the post is literally, "Completely useless."

LuvDWayULie: EXTREMELY erratic and chaotic. He's new, but I don't find that as an acceptable excuse. I would expect someone new to be far more passive, and maybe overreact to votes, but he hasn't done the first and only recently has done the second. At one point he actually asks flat out, "Who should we lynch?" He votes for Niernen because of supporting No Lynch....that he supported himself earlier. What? At another point he, (from my own notes) "Notes that he is a new player, and is going with the majority, which is frankly terrible." Going with the majority just helps the mafia get lynches on good people, as they will jump on the majority themselves. This highly supports a mafia status.

For these reasons I'm going to [Vote] LuvDWayULie He is currently the most suspicious to me. Why not TheBirds? Because inactivity can be dealt with later. Sega is a prime example of inactivity not necessarily meaning mafia. We don't know about TheBirds, there's just not enough information because they haven't said anything, while we have plenty of people who have said a little too much (myself included, I would be surprised if no one suspected me anymore because of how badly I handled Day 1). Why not ChaoticCJ? If he's right, and was voting to save himself, then it's not so bad. I'm still unsure of how that tiebreaker would have been handled, and I'll be significantly less suspicious of CJ if he was right and he had to save himself.

Slightly Suspicious To Me:
CakesXD: He votes for VerrKol at one point and claims that VerrKol is being erratic, but I don't see that at all. His votes all were in attempt to get people to talk. It's not much, but I got pomegranate on for not revealing every little thought so here you guys go.

Corn: His very early posts are extremely angry. He mentions more than once that he's both an apple and a corn. While it's probably flavor/random/irrelevant/based on his username, it seems really weird to me. He covers LuvDaWayULie's chaoticness quoting that he's new...after 1 or 2 people have already given him that excuse, so why? Except to try to add more support to a fellow mafioso.

Shidoshi: At least once Shidoshi has given votes without explanation, which we later had to drag out of them, especially towards CakesXD in Day 2. The last minute vote towards ChaoticCJ is a little offputting, especially since if ChaoticCJ is to be believed, it would have gotten him killed yet Shidoshi mentioned that, "[they] don't think it will do anything." That's a little weird, considering Shidoshi was keeping vote tally earlier the same day, so they would know what would and would not do something. Above that, I specifically asked them about how the tiebreaking lynch works and was ignored. Why? They've hosted games before and the rules for this game were practically a copypasta of their game, so they would know how it worked.

KhainiWest: The recent postings are a great example, and my point is outlined above in regards to those. His flavor crumbs were apparently received by no one, even the person they were aimed at (me). While that doesn't necessarily mean mafia I don't really get it. He also started off with some random chats about fresh apple cider with Niernen, but then uses cannibalism as an excuse to be suspicious of Niernen. Then it's an acceptable excuse to be suspicious of Khaini as well (Note there's two links in here).

[MENTION=13694]faonkarino[/MENTION]; Satisfied?