Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory

Strong suspicions, I definitely agree with. Even semi-strong suspicions. However, if I only slightly suspect someone with barely anything to support my suspicion, I'm more likely to create some confirmation bias instead, which works against us.

See, this is exactly why I don't like revealing small suspicions. I do it once, and now I'm getting voted for. I only had slight suspicions of him based on a good point others brought up, which he has since addressed himself and I have since stopped suspecting. There was a good point brought up, but ganging up on a guy over one point is illogical, which is why I didn't do it. Then he addressed it himself earlier and now I'm back to watching. Right now there's no one that I suspect enough to bring up anymore, and I'm defending that line of thinking against the people who think we should blurt out every single thought that comes to your mind about people (at least, that's how I took it). At the time there was a good point brought up on Holypie.

Pointing out suspicions is the name of the game. If you start getting voted for it, prove your innocence. Convince them that they are in the wrong for their vote. Holding back thoughts and information because you're scared of dying isn't helping the town at all.

I strongly stand by the idea that no thought is unimportant. The second you start second guessing yourself and writing off thoughts as irrelevant is the second you start letting the mafia slip by you. The more you keep thoughts to yourself, the more you're going to believe (or others are going to believe, if nobody else has said anything either) that their beliefs are in the wrong. Small details are how you know when the mafia starts slipping up. Pointing fingers and throwing out ideas or suspicions are, in my opinion, a vital aspect of that. I suppose this could still be argued extensively, but I digress. I don't really think I need to say anything else because it's not exactly helping anything - I could be using this time to scumhunt more.

Either way, it feels to me like you're being a bit too unnecessarily defensive and scared, and it's starting to seem like you're a bit of a mafia.


I'm...Craig? I only remember that because I was going to photoshop a picture of a blue chullo hat on an apple but got too lazy.
Crabapple craig.

edit: I'm not going to take that out, but saying our names might be a bit detrimental? There's the possibility that names are tied to power roles and I don't want to see the town die because they say their name.
Sour Sheila, for instance, seems like an awfully suspicious name.