Two Island Mafia - Discussion Thread

Because he didn't want you to lynch him... but that was definitely a shock for me too.

I think having a limited cop and doctor left the town a bit underpowered. Island hoping also became too suspicious (partly thanks to me getting us to lynch them) to be the frequent mechanic I think Shidoshi intended it to be. Polantaris/Dusk needed to use his power more often (at all) but there seemed little incentive to do so. If I had moved him I would have voted for him, especially after the fake cop spheal.

I would have like to see a god event that randomized island locations just to shake things up when it got a little slow.

I was going to move Corn to our island during the only night I had the ability to (since I wasn't playing for any of the other nights), because I didn't like him from the beginning. I even submitted the PM to Shidoshi but then cancelled it because I felt that the other island was going to become too easy to reach a majority if there were more mafia then survivors there.

The lack of participation overall was definitely a hindrance.

I think this was the overall problem with the entire game. Too many survivors were suspicious because they didn't do anything. Dusk, before I showed, Niernen, and Meta, at the very least were all Survivors but they didn't participate which made far too many suspects and far too little evidence to suspect anyone in particular. Silence is the tool of the Mafia in these games.

I suspected you slightly, but not enough to vote for you right then. It seemed to convenient for you to jump on my Zelkova vote. However, Holypie didn't help by completely ignoring Meta, although I was almost positive he was fine after he revealed his name. The names seemed important simply because, at least at the time, the only person who didn't have a first and last name with the same first letter was Zelkova, who was Mafia.

I didn't trust Corn at all, I explained exactly why in my post near the end. But, no one was really supporting me, and Niernen did absolutely nothing to keep himself alive but wasn't Mafia, which annoys me.

I will agree, xBTAx was a complete surprise. But then again, what did he contribute on the last day? And the first day? Nothing, that I remember. It shouldn't have been as big of a surprise as it was. He participated just enough to get out of the spotlight.