2014-06-01, 11:38 AM
Polantaris Wrote:Then he should opt out, like Dusk did. We have subs for a reason. Dusk opted out in the Discussion thread, there's no reason Niernen can't.
I can't speak for him, I'm just stating possibilities.
Polantaris Wrote:I disagree. Having two cops that are limited severely weakens the Survivors, and considering they only get so many days having them weakened is just making the game that much easier for the Pirafia to win, especially since Sega's ability was VERY limiting. It would have been useless for 90% of the game anyway since people only moved on the first day. There's no guarantee people will move, and thus that ability is far too situation based to be part of the full Investigation team, in my opinion. A very possible situation is the one we have here, and therefore Sega wouldn't even be able to do anything.
What? Corn is 90% of a normal cop, and having Sega gives the possibility of even more information, even if it doesn't play out. There are some roles that basically force island changes anyway, like those of Words and TheBirds. How does having more cops weaken the town? The town usually does fine with a single cop, there is no "investigation team". From a balancing point of view it would be crazy to introduce even a minor investigative role with no nerfs.
Polantaris Wrote:Silent people can very clearly be a threat. If I didn't call out Zelkova, I don't think he would have gotten lynched, because only one other person voted for him. If VerrKol is part of a bussing play, that just means that there would be even more pirafia left, because the bussing would have never occurred in the first place. The simple fact of the matter is that there's more than 2 pirafia, and as such there's no reason to be lynching VerrKol right now when there are far more suspicious candidates.
Silent people are a good target early in the game but now there's tons of information out there to make a solid lynch based on scumhunting and cop information. If I were to pick between Niernen (just quiet basically) and VerrKol (voted with a pirafia, bussed that same pirafia, and is accused of being pirafia by a potential cop), I think the choice is pretty obvious.
Polantaris Wrote:Yes, Bussing happens, but considering there's more than a few other people who are acting suspiciously, it's not an important fact right now. In a day, sure, but right now there's far worse going on, like the dual cop issue, both of which are on Island B so you need to figure that out. One of those two are pirafia, and in my opinion Corn has more against him than Meta does. I can do nothing but offer my opinion, which you're clearly not going to take, so really why bother more than this while I'm not on that island?
Yes, we're going to figure that out. We're getting quite close to lylo (lynch or lose) and mylo (mislynch and lose) which, while slightly complicated by the islands system, means that waiting to see if Corn is right is going to let VerrKol live another day. Additionally, lynching VerrKol will give us more information about Corn's cop status. Can you do a comparison between Corn and Meta? I don't see why he's more suspicious. I'm considering your opinion, I just don't think you're right about Niernen and VerrKol.
Polantaris Wrote:Lucy Lola. I support the request for everyone to submit their names.
Have to go to bed now, I won't be back before the end of the day, and I'm not changing my vote, so if everyone decides Niernen is not worth the lynch, then figure out who is quickly.
I'm telling you, please vote for VerrKol.

