2014-06-01, 01:16 AM
Holypie Wrote:Okay then, I'm not going to ask you to reveal your role, but please tell me, do you believe that your ability is worth more than a potential pirafia kill AS WELL AS a potential confirmed cop? If you do, then please by all means, save your own skin. Just know that it means the pirafia will probably win. Unless, you are a pirafia, which I seriously believe. Also really only the first if matters because the second one is a direct consequence of that. But I digress. It doesn't really matter if no pirafia have been found on island B so far? It's been mentioned several times that the pirafia might be stacking to one island in order to cap the potential pirafia deaths to one per day and guaranteeing an innocent lynch.
Seriously guys? Just because Niernen isn't helpful doesn't mean that you IGNORE A COP'S INVESTIGATION. Also can you explain what you mean by my votes ending in an innocent's death in the night?
I'm putting everything on the line for this, because I think it's right. Besides, it's very unusual for a pirafia to counterclaim a cop. The much more common scenario is that a pirafia is backed into a corner and comes out as a cop as a last ditch effort to live for a while longer, and then the real cop counterclaims. This isn't all the time, but I think this is what's going on now. If you think I'm suspicious because I've suddenly been posting a whole lot more, it's because I'm having a lot of fun and scenarios like this are why I play mafia. I think this is great but you guys should really kill VerrKol. Damn if I'm wrong I'm going to look so guilty.
Except this late in the game we can't afford kill off any innocents because the pirates could very quickly reach a majority. Killing either Corn or Meta confirms the other is a cop unless you think they are both mafia and up to some serious shenanigans? The pirates can't be stacking on island A because no one has switched islands since day 1! If we make the basic assumption that there are 4 pirates and that they began evenly distributed across both islands, there is 1 more on A and 2 on B. It's possible there are fewer, but I consider it highly suspect that you seem to think there is one or none on B. You are still ignoring that Polantaris and I are the only two to vote for a confirmed Pirate. Why would a pirate lynch another pirate with only 2 votes?
You're ignoring a cop's investigation all by yourself. You ignore that Meta believes Corn is the pirate, but since he says you're innocent he must be the legit cop!
You're logic is horribly inconsistent and I no longer believe you are a mere survivor.
Let's add up the facts.
1. You have voted to lynch several innocents
2. You back the "cop" that says you're innocent
3. You finger one of 2 people who voted to lynch a pirate
1+2+3 = Holypie is a pirate likely backed by Corn (and maybe Niernen since he's defending him)