Two Island Mafia - Pirafia Win

Is it possible for there to be no pirafia members on Island A though? So far we have seen only one death and its been on Island B, if we assume it takes a whole night to swim over should we assume town can only be killed on the same islands the pirafia is?

Otherwise we are left with Zelkova being the most suspicious, verrkol seems in a safeish spot, but with the addition of polantaris we are in a rough spot in Island A

Just because they have people on both islands doesn't mean that they are guaranteed kills on each island, otherwise they'd be able to pick off people far too quickly. Making the assumption that there's 3-4 pirafia, that would mean they'd be able to take everyone out in 4-5 days and that's not even including accidental lynches (12 players, 3 pirafia = everyone dead in 5 days, 4 pirafia = everyone dead in 4 days). That'd make it too easy for them. No, they probably just have no island restriction on who they can kill (So they could all be on one island and kill someone on the other).

You make a good point, mafia would easily be able to sway votes, but at the moment it seems like they dont have to since people are being voted off rather quickly. Thing is polantaris could be mafia but he hasnt been here the whole time so it'll be hard. I think our best bet is him or Zelkova, thoughts ChaoticCJ;?

If you look over the previous days, you can see exactly what I'm saying about Zelkova. He rarely has any input except to attempt to lynch someone, and even in response to my vote on him he did exactly what I expected - not vote me (because I called him out on it), but vote on someone who has been overall helpful as another distraction.

If I'm wrong I'm gonna look like a jackass (and massive pirafia, of course), but right now I don't see him doing anything that is beneficial except pointing fingers.