Two Island Mafia - Pirafia Win

VerrKol;
Words was one of the more vocal members here.
Claiming you wouldn't have lynched Words is both an easy claim to make and highly inconsistent. It was the end of the day and you shouldn't be voting anyone without an intention to lynch them, if not to gauge reactions early on.
I never claimed the votes were my sole reasoning - it was an extension of my previous analysis, if you saw my previous statements on the matter. The way a vote is carried out means just as much as the vote itself.
And you have done very little actual scumhunting. You have literally just mimicked what others have already said.

All points are irrelevant.


And I agree with CJ. Revenge voting is silly. OMGUS as it's called is very inconsistent and trivializes most legitimate scumhunting.

Pardon? I voted hours (28 irl) prior to the day ending. If you read my original post, it's fairly obvious I did it to provoke a reaction and try to get him to explain his island hop (said as much in post #111). You can note that I was the first and only vote for him that day (irl time). What exactly about the "way I voted" is suspicious? You can and should look for alterior motives in everything I say/do

I have mimicked no one. I was the first and only person to suggest that pirates might island hop to concentrate their numbers and skew lynch votes for instance (#89). Granted, this hasn't happened at least thus far, but it was a more viable idea than any others presented at the time. I grant that I have made some inconsequential posts for flavor, but I've also contributed more theories and opinions on possible pirates than many others in this thread.

I propose a new possible strategy. We have a number of people on both islands who are contributing very little and largely not voting at all. It is highly possible that one or more of these are pirates attempting to lay low. Alternatively, they are simply shipwrecked people that aren't helping to detect pirates and therefore of little value to the survivors if it's a bad lynch.

The people matching this description are:
Niernen (A)
Dusk (A)
MetaSeraphim (B)
xBTAx (B)

[MENTION=2796]y0y0y0y0shi0[/MENTION]; What do you think about this idea? (honest question no sarcasm attached)