Two Island Mafia - Pirafia Win

And ours seem to consist of:
Someone who fell under the powers of salesmen (Verrkol)
Someone who likes alcohol (Dusk)
Someone whose main concern is the heat (ImagineAll)
Someone who seems cynical and paranoid (ChaoticCJ)
Someone who is brooks from one piece (Sega)
Someone trying to survive (Niernen)
An optimistic person (Zelkova)
And someone who is worried about coconut milk (myself)

Now that that's out of the way, my best guesses are CHatoicCJ due to the paranoia and since brook is a pirate, Sega.