IS HE JUSTIFIED?

I'd probably stay the f'uck away from anything like that. Don't want my grip on reality to be slippin. Watching the cultural/news/societal/idontquiteknowthewordforthis shitstorm that would erupt would be very entertaining though.

Understandable, me personally if it were to ever exist in my lifetime I might give it a try. You already lose track of reality with any game that requires alot of attention and concentration (e.g Dota) well at least I do, but of course when the game ends you are like oh yeh real life. Everyone should know their limits.

But that would probably be one of the biggest selling points of such a system, an escapist's paradise. Oh the abnormal behaviors that consume the mainstream.

Totally. So much fun to watch a person scream at a horror game he's clearly not actually being scared by. Hilarious.

Lol postulation, such critic, granted that is simply your experience so fair enough. Furthermore the point of his videos, from my observation, was to entertain which was accomplished, not review the game and beat it to a pulp like a hardcore gamer. Burden of proof would is too heavy with such a claim, and it really doesn't matter if one person finds it fake, general perception is everything when it comes to entertainment and the proof of that can be seen with the ratio of likes to dislikes and/or views.