KMST v1.2.495 - You & I (The Seed)

Depending on what kind of scrolls you use:

Scroll	Scrolled	5 stars	10 stars	12 stars
+5	+15	+71	+133	+159
+8	+24	+81	+144	+171
+9	+27	+84	+147	+174
+10	+30	+88	+152	+180

Compare to Empress:

Scroll	Scrolled	5 stars	10 stars	12 stars
+5	+50	+75	+102	+114
+8	+80	+108	+138	+152
+9	+90	+120	+152	+166
+10	+100	+130	+163	+177

And Fafnir:

Scroll	Scrolled	5 stars	10 stars	12 stars
+5	+50	+80	+112	+126
+8	+80	+112	+147	+163
+9	+90	+124	+160	+176
+10	+100	+135	+173	+189

If I did my math right, anyway.

The values in each cell (except for the ones in the first column) are the magic attack that would be transposed to a Sweetwater.

So it'd be better, but only barely, unless +10 scrolls, in which case Fafnir is better...

So overall it'd just be better on its own unless you'd want the set effects?