Let's Temporarily

I did the calculations at level 120. I left out equips that equally benefit both sides including gloves (Flamekeeper Cordon).

Matk score = ( matk - ( level * 5 + 18 ) )

Hat: [Zakum Helmet] 15 Int/15 Luk
Overall: [Green Starlight] 4 Int/1 Luk
Shoes: [Yellow Snowshoes] 5 Int
Pendant: [Horntail Pendant] 22 Int/22 Luk
Weapon: [Shine Wand/Wisdom Staff] 80 matk/1 Int

Matk Score for Lukless: 127

Hat: [Zakum Helmet] 15 Int/15 Luk
Overall: [Dark Requiem] 5 Int/2 Luk
Shoes: [Lapiz Sandals] 8 Stats
Pendant: [Horntail Pendant] 22 Int/22 Luk
Weapon: [Doomsday Staff] 118 Matk

Matk Score for Luk: 127


Unless I made a mistake, both sides are equal on paper. However, it's easier and cheaper to scroll Lukless equipment since Shine Wands are still cheap and overalls are readily available from NPCs.

I think the maker skill will change alot of things in favor of LUK...
even if it is a year away...