2013-11-23, 07:32 AM
Watched both.
People want fast gameplay, a sense of action, and humour. I would go as far as to say that the editing and commentary actually made the videos worse. If someone wanted to watch a HT solo by a BM, they would look up an unedited version. If they wanted a Maple MV, they would expect more fitting music and a range of footage in the video. If they wanted some satire vid on how easy bosses have become (eg. like soloing pap with puppet), they would include more humour.
You need to figure out what exactly you want to do with the videos, rather than just place random commentary together with semi-edited footage.
People want fast gameplay, a sense of action, and humour. I would go as far as to say that the editing and commentary actually made the videos worse. If someone wanted to watch a HT solo by a BM, they would look up an unedited version. If they wanted a Maple MV, they would expect more fitting music and a range of footage in the video. If they wanted some satire vid on how easy bosses have become (eg. like soloing pap with puppet), they would include more humour.
You need to figure out what exactly you want to do with the videos, rather than just place random commentary together with semi-edited footage.