Project Nostalgia

I must've missed that then. I apologize. May I suggest Broa then?
Seeing as Broa is currently lacking in population in general, according to a GMS server population tracker I just found.

How many southperry members are in Broa? I know I play in broa a lot on my bowmaster at the least.

But it really depresses me that this many people are going against the rules. I thought half the fun was struggling with the guild to level as a group, breaking the rules just ruins the point of the guild in general. I can get why people do it, but it's just sad really.

I also feel that we should keep the rules simple and easy to understand.
I feel that having a bunch of vague exceptions will just confuse people. Not to mention many are hard to keep track of, and I don't feel they would be worth the trouble.
Though I second... third... fourth the idea of shop permits being allowed.