![[Image: SPSymbol.png]](http://IMG.photobucket.com/albums/v19/Macie59/Southperry/SPSymbol.png)
![[Image: splogo_zpsec65bbbb.png]](http://IMG.photobucket.com/albums/v19/Macie59/Southperry/splogo_zpsec65bbbb.png)
![[Image: spfeather.png]](http://IMG.photobucket.com/albums/v19/Macie59/Southperry/spfeather.png)
![[Image: sp_extractor.png]](http://IMG.photobucket.com/albums/v19/Macie59/Southperry/sp_extractor.png)
![[Image: Slogoclean.png]](http://IMG.photobucket.com/albums/v19/Macie59/Southperry/Slogoclean.png)
![[Image: newfavicon.png]](http://IMG.photobucket.com/albums/v19/Macie59/Southperry/newfavicon.png)
2012-10-17, 05:33 PM
1) Is probably the best one but I still like the old icon.
2) I just don't like the black background. I don't like icons with a picture surrounded by a colored background because then it's just a square... Perhaps instead of just a black background, there would be a thick black (or SouthPerry Blue) around the feather.
3) I like it because it's like the old icon except it has the site initials and it reminds me of Skill Points (and it's shaped like a Skill to put points in). This lightly reminisces a significant part of SouthPerry which are the extractions.
4) It's clever to use an extractor for the extractions but they could have made the effort to be conservative with the color scheme... I would've liked it better :S. Of course, extractions aren't the only thing at SouthPerry so it's kinda leaning too hard into one part of the site. #3 has that lighter touch and achieves the same thing. Also I don't like pictures as logos... I like simple shapes or letters.
5) It would look better as a white anchor. Also the S looks kinda messy :S. It reminds me too much of a world selection icon... most of which are pretty bleh imo.
6) This would be okay if site changes its colors to red... which is not something I would want personally.
-
I picked 3 but 1 is ok I guess...
2) I just don't like the black background. I don't like icons with a picture surrounded by a colored background because then it's just a square... Perhaps instead of just a black background, there would be a thick black (or SouthPerry Blue) around the feather.
3) I like it because it's like the old icon except it has the site initials and it reminds me of Skill Points (and it's shaped like a Skill to put points in). This lightly reminisces a significant part of SouthPerry which are the extractions.
4) It's clever to use an extractor for the extractions but they could have made the effort to be conservative with the color scheme... I would've liked it better :S. Of course, extractions aren't the only thing at SouthPerry so it's kinda leaning too hard into one part of the site. #3 has that lighter touch and achieves the same thing. Also I don't like pictures as logos... I like simple shapes or letters.
5) It would look better as a white anchor. Also the S looks kinda messy :S. It reminds me too much of a world selection icon... most of which are pretty bleh imo.
6) This would be okay if site changes its colors to red... which is not something I would want personally.
-
I picked 3 but 1 is ok I guess...