Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory

Not necessarily gonna make a whole lot of difference, but: [Vote] ChaoticCJ

Unfortunately, voting for "he seems scummy" is the name of the game.

And again, only responding when called out. "I don't want to vote randomly but I'll vote randomly for self-preservation." Again, scummy.

Oh then I will let myself die, since the "town" wants to lynch me. I won't try to save myself since the town is so capable of rallying around a vote.

What would you expect anyone to do? If I voted for you, you wouldn't try to save yourself?

And again, what do you want me to say. I know who the mafia is...its obviously yoshi and Shidoshi. I have no basis for this claim other than you are extra eager to reduce the amount of townies.

Now I have to [vote] Sega. In hopes that granny isn't necessarily too helpful.

[COLOR="#cc8899"]Aaaaaand scene. Tallying votes.

As the day draws to a close, everyone continues arguing. Many names are shouted, but one edges out ahead of the rest - [MENTION=5147]Sega[/MENTION];

Grudgingly, the dissenters let up, and you all call his name out to the Robin on the fence. It flies over to the branch [MENTION=5147]Sega[/MENTION]; hangs from and pecks at his stem until he falls. He lands directly on a fence post, impaling him and violently de-coring him.

You are Green Gendry, a Granny Smith Apple. You have no power but your vote and win if all threats to the tree are eliminated.

It is now Night 1. All players with Night actions may send PMs to me dictating how they want their actions to be used. Night 1 will end on Saturday the 14th at noon PST.[/COLOR]

[COLOR="#cc8899"]When the sun comes out in the morning, it shines on a gruesome sight. Bits of applesauce cover the branch where [MENTION=2796]y0y0y0y0shi0[/MENTION]; used to hang in a pulpy mess.

It is now Day 2. Day 2 will end at noon PST on the 16th (Monday).[/COLOR]

You are Crabapple Craig, a McIntosh apple. You have no power but your vote and win if all threats to the tree are eliminated.

Killing y0y0y0y0shi0 seems like two birds with one stone for the mafia. Off an active player and incriminate ChaoticCJ. I don't want to write off suspicion on CJ just yet, but I think there are others that should take the fall first.
[Vote] CakesXD

Why CakesXD first? I think CJ is incredibly suspicious with his last minute vote for Sega. Then again, if he is mafia why would he finger yoshi and then immediately kill him off revealing him as innocent? Unless the goal was to also make you, Shidoshi, seem innocent by association. There is also the other possibility that he's innocent and has an overwhelming sense of self preservation, despite it being quite anti-town. Agh, this is a mess.

Why CakesXD first? I think CJ is incredibly suspicious with his last minute vote for Sega. Then again, if he is mafia why would he finger yoshi and then immediately kill him off revealing him as innocent? Unless the goal was to also make you, Shidoshi, seem innocent by association. There is also the other possibility that he's innocent and has an overwhelming sense of self preservation, despite it being quite anti-town. Agh, this is a mess.

I'd think the last option is most likely. His vote on Sega was inconsequential, he was already going to be lynched, even without his vote.

From my understanding lurkers are the easiest to target and get rid of first, because they aren't there to defend themselves and are seen as observers. My suspicions would default be Olsi/Corn, I don't give much credi to holypie since again, he's new, and was just lured in by the logic from olsi. A sheep if you will.

Corn immediately jumped to saying not lynching is wasting everyones turn essentially. Although Yoshi agreed with him, so this maybe simply experience. So I feel Olsi is the more likely contender, especially when he says he's trying to apply logic, yet his rebuttal for his original vote was simply making a statement of that fact.

I'm pretty sure metaseraphim is exaggerating alcohol or her drunkin banter (attempted), is important subtext* unfortunately I'm not familiar with mafia roles so maybe someone else can make sense of this.

Polaritis was very defensive, but the type of defense that seemed like "wrongdoing", rather than "caught lying". Shidoshi is also on my list since he seems the most apathetic* about all of this, but again, perhaps experience.

Olsi was the first to call attention to Sega's silence. Despite not voting him, Olsi called attention to him several times (and to others)..

Youre right that I did call attention to sega because of his extreme quietness but im 100% sure I voted for him, I was just unable to bold cause I was on mobile and southperry constantly crashes on my phone.

Edit: Im gonna have to agree with shidoshi's comment, it would be too easy for CJ to be mafia, killing the person who first points a finger at you does not seem like the best plan to stay hidden.

And if Sega paid attention to the huge amount of times I mentioned him for being quiet and said something he could have turned things around, hell even by throwing a vote on the second most voted person with a good reason would have saved him i think.

Corn immediately jumped to saying not lynching is wasting everyones turn essentially. Although Yoshi agreed with him, so this maybe simply experience. So I feel Olsi is the more likely contender, especially when he says he's trying to apply logic, yet his rebuttal for his original vote was simply making a statement of that fact.

Corn always advocates early lynching in any game. It's not overly indicative of anything.
I think Olsi has earned at least some suspicion, but it's circumstantial.

I hadn't considered Meta for role hinting. Does anyone have experience with a village drunk role? It's the only thought I have there.

EDIT: [MENTION=6616]Olsi[/MENTION]; Guess I'll hunt through things again to check on that.

Corn always advocates early lynching in any game. It's not overly indicative of anything.
I think Olsi has earned at least some suspicion, but it's circumstantial.

I hadn't considered Meta for role hinting. Does anyone have experience with a village drunk role? It's the only thought I have there.

EDIT: Olsi; Guess I'll hunt through things again to check on that.

Meta has been playing the drunk act really hard (at least at the start), a quick little search says he is able to visit one person per night and act as a role block.
Edit: Does that mean he could block the detective or doctor as well as the mafia members?

What is something that is red and bad for your teeth?

A brick!

Bahahahahaha.

Maybe we should focus on the other people who didn't actually vote

Yeah, who the hell is vote Kyrastri?

Maybe we should focus on the other people who didn't actually vote

hey bby ur pretty hot, mebbe i should come over to ur branch

Since meta has already pretty much given his role I think its safe to say he used his night action on me last night, although I guess that is kinda irrelevant.

As for those that did not vote ([MENTION=4235]KhainiWest[/MENTION], they are KhainiWest, Niernen, Polantaris, Sega, TheBirds, xBTAx, z0mgc00k13.

Edit: so meta if you wanna disclose some information, do you know if you also block the town's actions

hey bby ur pretty hot, mebbe i should come over to ur branch

I don't deal with coreless apples.

Since meta has already pretty much given his role I think its safe to say he used his night action on me last night, although I guess that is kinda irrelevant.

As for those that did not vote (KhainiWest, they are KhainiWest, Niernen, Polantaris, Sega, TheBirds, xBTAx, z0mgc00k13.

Edit: so meta if you wanna disclose some information, do you know if you also block the town's actions

My opinion is between "TheBirds" and zomgcookie, neither have posted anything significant and haven't been significantly challenged. BTA wasn't available, Neirnen and polantaris are also eligible. Considering the "Apple Cider" comment. Of course I'm also a culprit but genuinely I missed the time, my vote personally was going to go for Olsi if I am to be honest. Although that is subject to change so don't take it too heart

Well, I'm sure some people did not have a chance to vote because they didn't realize when the cut off time was... Then again, it always gets very srs when it comes close to lynching time. Meta seems like he had a little too much "cider", although it could just be an act to make it look like he is an active villager when he is really a drunk mafia member. (Or I'm really bad at guessing roles). I guess we will see how this plays out.


And my internet keeps crashing every 5 minutes

Since meta has already pretty much given his role I think its safe to say he used his night action on me last night, although I guess that is kinda irrelevant.

Really now? That's funny, because I used my night action on Words last night and got a very interesting result.


But from what you say you have a night action and it was blocked last night? Even more interesting.