Anyone else having problems with maker lvl2?

So I've Failed upgrading maker lvl1->lvl2 2 times now..... anyone else have this problem?

I'm lvl 87, made 2 crystals out of may mists both times he said they were abominable and said try again

just bad luck haha. mine worked first try

I failed about 3 times in a row before it decided the crystal was any good.

I failed it twice and then it worked on the third try. You'll just have to keep trying until it works.

I failed about 3 times in a row before it decided the crystal was any good.

I failed it twice and then it worked on the third try. You'll just have to keep trying until it works.

maybe the third time is the charm! hopefully my next one isn't crap so i can finally meet my goal and move on to working on my KoC

Mine worked first try. Yesterday was a lucky day for me.

Friend failed 6. I worked my third one. It's just random.

It failed four times before it finally worked. I was starting to RAGE!!

He accepted the 3rd crystal I handed him. I'd got the crystals from disassembling an average DT.

Meren's so picky, considering he can't even make a golden anvil for himself T_T

Mine worked at the third time

Worked the first time like a charm.

i got mine on the 8th try lmaoo

It occurs in JMS too,just get Lucida etc drops instead of them,dunno why,but homuncullus etc drops has this problem,just get some lucida etc drops.
With them,it works in the first try.

Got maker lv 2 first go, Meren(or is it Moren?) said something like that he didnt really like it but would accept it anyway. lol

so i'm really unlucky cause i'm at 7 fails and still no passes...