Southperry.net
#Gamergate - Printable Version

+- Southperry.net (https://www.southperry.net)
+-- Forum: Arts & Entertainment (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=12)
+--- Forum: General Entertainment (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=71)
+---- Forum: General Gaming (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=74)
+---- Thread: #Gamergate (/showthread.php?tid=72381)



#Gamergate - KhainiWest - 2014-08-24

For a girl who's a "victim" she certainly likes to pick a lot of fights.


#Gamergate - Curtiss - 2014-08-24

Oh boy, this sure is a delicious update.

https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/the-fine-young-capitalists--2#home - Taken down
http://zvunderbahr.tumblr.com/post/95623249067/thefineyoungcapitalists-indiegogo-page-is-hacked - A look at what happened

It could be someone trying to make use of Zoe's bad publicity, but given everything that's happened it's not very likely. Thoughts?


#Gamergate - PoetryIsFail - 2014-08-24

Holy crap I can barely keep up with all of this. Damn.

Shame the campaign got taken down 3:


#Gamergate - ChickenKiev - 2014-08-24

Curtiss Wrote:Oh boy, this sure is a delicious update.

https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/the-fine-young-capitalists--2#home - Taken down
http://zvunderbahr.tumblr.com/post/95623249067/thefineyoungcapitalists-indiegogo-page-is-hacked - A look at what happened

It could be someone trying to make use of Zoe's bad publicity, but given everything that's happened it's not very likely. Thoughts?

Notice the capitalized "V" - The Fine Young Capitalists need to investigate this. They need to ask Indiegogo which IP/MAC addresses were accessing the page during the time of the hacking.


#Gamergate - Curtiss - 2014-08-24

ChickenKiev Wrote:Notice the capitalized "V" - The Fine Young Capitalists need to investigate this. They need to ask Indiegogo which IP/MAC addresses were accessing the page during the time of the hacking.

They've recently made a statement on the incident after being contacted, so that's probably going to happen soon.

The good news is that no one's money has been touched or compromised because of it, but being one of the backers I could care less who's actually responsible (Most likely Zoe and co., but I will admit that it's easy to pin blame on them) so much as being mad that this happened when the money was going for a good cause.


#Gamergate - xBTAx - 2014-08-24

Kubi Wrote:To be honest, I didn't even know who this lady was before clicking on this thread. But from reading through everything I come across as well as doing some of my own research on the matter... She just can't be trusted, as I can just see her as a selfish hypocrite. There are so many sides to this, and from the looks of it she's just been trying to spin the blame/criticisms and play the innocent/victim/blame/etc cards, while this Phil Fish guy is doing the same while acting like he's having a temper tantrum just cause people don't agree or support him. The more they do with these random stunts and behavior, the deeper they're digging themselves.

I don't trust her releasing her game called 'Depression Quest' (if you can even call it a game, when it could well be a book) on the day of Robin William's death to actually help people. Whatever way you look at it, it's downright respectful to the people that do care about Robin. Couldn't it have waited until later when people aren't still shocked or mourning over him and give some breathing space or consideration? So, it's pretty clear to me that she's just trying to gain publicity in whatever way she can. It's similar to what PeTA does to gain publicity, doesn't matter if it's good or bad - pulling stunts and trying to leech off big news. In the case for this lady, she started something big that spiraled out of her control. I don't want to sound like a jerk, but this is what her arrogance can do. They think they can fool the people to gain support, cause they thought up of a plan that couldn't possibly fail, with those victim/feminism/etc cards as backup... But when it actually backfires and runs out of cards, she's going through drastic measures in trying to clear herself as innocent. So it seems like she's just trying to pull off whatever stunt she can to protect herself while trying put the blame/topic on something else.

She got approval to release it on Steam minutes before the news broke. She asked on Twitter if people wanted her to release it still or to wait a while because she was worried about it being seen as this. Many people said they found the game helpful to them and so she should release it.

EDIT: Ugh I wrote a lot more but it got deleted when I scrolled on my phone and it went back, so:

1. Despite my clear issues with TFYC, they didn't deserve to get hacked or anything like that, and I hope they do track down who it was.
2. The problem with their "women making games" thing while centering it around the ideas is, well, that the only woman guaranteed to be involved is the winner whose name they'll stick on it, as opposed to using female developers, and backers can morph that idea so even that involvement is limited. Not only are women not actually making the game, but that's not even something the winner can really put on their resume and gain any benefit from like they claim, so the contest is pretty flawed from an actually helping women standpoint. That's part of the problem, beyond the percentage of money thing being so low.
3. The trans issue is that many trans women who would need a contest like this to make their game likely would not be able to afford (and even then, don't necessarily want) bottom surgery. This was said to them at the time. It's my understanding that their policy is more open now, though, so good on them if that's the case.

EDIT2:

Also, Khaini, I don't get my information from "news sites".


#Gamergate - Flonne - 2014-08-24

xBTAx Wrote:She got approval to release it on Steam minutes before the news broke. She asked on Twitter if people wanted her to release it still or to wait a while because she was worried about it being seen as this. Many people said they found the game helpful to them and so she should release it.

It's quite easy to gather support when you are what people see as a "self-empowered independent woman". When that is the case, no matter how shitty your product, people will eat it up in scenes such as indie gaming, because it makes them feel good when they think they are working toward a cause. Because they don't care about games, they care about causes.

As a person with suicidal depression, I can say that fucking game is absolutely worthless and more importantly a mockery of the entire issue; people have the freedom to put out whatever horseshit they want, but that didn't even deserve acknowledgment as a game, much less a steam greenlight. It's even less of a game than Gone Home, and that is a feat in and of itself.


#Gamergate - KhainiWest - 2014-08-24

xBTAx Wrote:She got approval to release it on Steam minutes before the news broke. She asked on Twitter if people wanted her to release it still or to wait a while because she was worried about it being seen as this. Many people said they found the game helpful to them and so she should release it.

She literally opened it to honor robin williams. That was the whole point of it.
xBTAx Wrote:2. The problem with their "women making games" thing while centering it around the ideas is, well, that the only woman guaranteed to be involved is the winner whose name they'll stick on it, as opposed to using female developers, and backers can morph that idea so even that involvement is limited. Not only are women not actually making the game, but that's not even something the winner can really put on their resume and gain any benefit from like they claim, so the contest is pretty flawed from an actually helping women standpoint. That's part of the problem, beyond the percentage of money thing being so low.

It was for exposure not resume, and the entire point is that they can't code, that's why they are participating. Whether it's female developers or not is an asinine detail, they are workers, bringing a female idea to life, to show what kind of dimension breaking games that the female mind can bring to us.

So again, you're wrong.

xBTAx Wrote:3. The trans issue is that many trans women who would need a contest like this to make their game likely would not be able to afford (and even then, don't necessarily want) bottom surgery. This was said to them at the time. It's my understanding that their policy is more open now, though, so good on them if that's the case.

Did you read anything I said? They used a definition that was fit for the LGBT, and that was never requirement in the first place. She assumed it was, so no, it wasn't a change in retaliation, there was no change at all.

EDIT2:

xBTAx Wrote:Also, Khaini, I don't get my information from "news sites".

Or anywhere reputable since your facts are all f`ucking wrong. Doesn't matter though, Zoe quinns career is officially and justifiably dead.


#Gamergate - IllegallySane - 2014-08-24

The plot thickens with another video out delving further into this. The more I read/look into this whole thing, the more I'm very sure Quinn is completely worthy AND deserving of being called a cu'nt.

[video=youtube;pKmy5OKg6lo]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pKmy5OKg6lo[/video]


#Gamergate - Malthe - 2014-08-24

xBTAx Wrote:3. The trans issue is that many trans women who would need a contest like this to make their game likely would not be able to afford (and even then, don't necessarily want) bottom surgery. This was said to them at the time. It's my understanding that their policy is more open now, though, so good on them if that's the case.

[Image: 41d.png]
THE RULES WERE ALWAYS LIKE THIS, THEY WERE NOT CHANGED.


#Gamergate - ChickenKiev - 2014-08-24

https://twitter.com/HeyZeusShaveZ/status/503325313107910656/photo/1
Zoe Quinn confirmed for making reddit take down any posts regarding her.


#Gamergate - Curtiss - 2014-08-24

Quote:She got approval to release it on Steam minutes before the news broke. She asked on Twitter if people wanted her to release it still or to wait a while because she was worried about it being seen as this. Many people said they found the game helpful to them and so she should release it.

Releasing the game quietly, she says as she blogs about this to her Tumblr followers

Quote:So I am launching the game. Quietly. I will not be promoting it until a respectful time later. But I want it to be out there and available in all the ways I can make it be available so that if someone needs it, they have it. After agonizing over it and asking the general public, they’ve overwhelmingly responded with pleas to release it. Especially among depression sufferers.

Quietly, she says when she BLATANTLY links an article about Robin Williams' suicide. I should also note here that while Depression Quest itself is free, she still has a Patreon account that has more or less doubled in subscription because people are jumping all over themselves to help poor oppressed Zoe, and in light of that it's actually clearer why she would sabotage TFNC; if they had gone viral and had the proper backing, Depression Quest would have been left in the dust and she wouldn't generate enough controversy to get the funding she needs.

Quote:The problem with their "women making games" thing while centering it around the ideas is, well, that the only woman guaranteed to be involved is the winner whose name they'll stick on it, as opposed to using female developers, and backers can morph that idea so even that involvement is limited. Not only are women not actually making the game, but that's not even something the winner can really put on their resume and gain any benefit from like they claim, so the contest is pretty flawed from an actually helping women standpoint. That's part of the problem, beyond the percentage of money thing being so low.

Did you even bother to check your facts?

1) The winner will be working with women: Lola Barreto is the director and founder of Autobotika, while Giovanna Baretto and Laura Benavides serve as the producer and animator respectively. Regardless of how much people modify the source code, the winner is always going to be the one having credits for her project.

2) And who says they can't put it on a resume? That's a pretty dumb assumption because people put all kinds of things in a resume, and coming up with a game design that wins a contest and gets made into a real product is far more impressive than most things people include in their resumes.

3) That 8% is completely theirs to use and the participants can leave at any time if they think that it's too low. That's not a bad deal considering that advertising itself is expensive and lots of people were getting on TFYC's founder's case simply for being a guy, because clearly every man must not want to help empower women.

http://thefineyoungcapitalists.tumblr.com/post/95547894105/im-not-sure-if-this-has-been-asked-but-wouldnt#notes
http://thefineyoungcapitalists.tumblr.com/post/95500441060/if-you-would-like-some-easy-ammo-against-people-hating#notes

As it is, these women have basically nowhere to turn to because even the one group trying to help them for free has SJWs coming after them, and Zoe's criticism of their work in spite of being completely wrong about the validity of their transgender policy no doubt helped to contribute to that.

Zero news of TFYC being hacked

The founder of the project mentioned that no one would publish what he had to say when he was doxxed previously, and now that /v/, Reddit, Twitter and some of Tumblr can verify the project being hacked it definitely looks like he was telling the truth about everything. This attack also came days after TFYC was criticized for taking 4Chan's money, so it at the very least sets an uncomfortable precedent.


#Gamergate - KhainiWest - 2014-08-24

He isn't going to see you quoting him unless it says "Quote=blahblah" so I'll just save the trouble for you [MENTION=3177]xBTAx[/MENTION];


#Gamergate - Zerard - 2014-08-24

ChickenKiev Wrote:https://twitter.com/HeyZeusShaveZ/status/503325313107910656/photo/1
Zoe Quinn confirmed for making reddit take down any posts regarding her.

wonder who she slept with to pull that off


#Gamergate - Curtiss - 2014-08-24

Thanks [MENTION=4235]KhainiWest[/MENTION];, but considering he's basically ignored the info I posted previously I don't expect much to come out of it.

Update on Reddit:

http://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/2eh4lv/rgames_mod_gets_booted_for_leaking_modlogs_and/
http://pastebin.com/MyrkRPE6 - Statement from said mod
http://pastebin.com/nqKG9XBq - The ban in question

This is relating to a Reddit mod posting a confession that Zoe did request them to remove everything about her.

Some people have been noting how shady this whole deal is, and I'm inclined to say that RebelJam and Patreon points to some scandal involving money at this point.


#Gamergate - ChickenKiev - 2014-08-25

Warning: The picture below will show Zoe Quinn to be a liar and hints at a more malevolent attitude towards The Fine Young Capitalists.

Pay close attention to the last two tweets on the right column - "whoops a site got accidentally doxxed" - how accidental was it, Zoe?

 Spoiler

You might look closer and notice that the @thequinnspiracy is all lower letters instead of her current Twitter, @TheQuinnspiracy. That's because @thequinnspiracy was her old Twitter handle.

Here's her old one: https://twitter.com/zoequinnzel
Here's her current one: https://twitter.com/TheQuinnspiracy

UPDATE:

Well now, this is interesting:
 Spoiler

Zoe admitted to her boyfriend that she was intimate with Nathan Grayson on the Las Vegas trip. When did this trip take place? Right around March 22, when he published an article on Kotaku covering his trip. Then there's a screenshot of Stephen Totilo saying that he believes Grayson and claimed the only time Grayson mentioned Zoe in an article was on March 31st. But that's not true, as he mentioned Zoe Quinn in the comments when the story's link was posted to Facebook. You could argue that he didn't include her in the actual article, but you can't deny the testimony that Zoe gave to her now ex-boyfriend.


#Gamergate - Curtiss - 2014-08-25

I went back through TFYC's Twitter and can confirm that those replies to them from Zoe's old account are true.

 Spoiler

Note that some of her followers mention having 'talked' about it as well before engaging with TFYC, which suggests that they planned it.


#Gamergate - KhainiWest - 2014-08-25

https://twitter.com/ObeliskDR/status/504066193431724032

I'm a terrible person


#Gamergate - Justin - 2014-08-25

KhainiWest Wrote:https://twitter.com/ObeliskDR/status/504066193431724032

I'm a terrible person

I wonder if she'll even respond to you. Rolleyes If so, this could turn into some good humor for a while.


#Gamergate - Zerard - 2014-08-25

I like how Zoe has the gall to pretend like she hasn't/isn't doing anything terribly wrong and instead of going through the radical changes she needs to, she rather just ignore it and play it off as if everything's peachy keen.

Are you even human