+- Southperry.net (https://www.southperry.net)
+-- Forum: Social (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=14)
+--- Forum: Forum Games & Unofficial Activities/Events (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=56)
+--- Thread: Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory (/showthread.php?tid=71446)
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - MasPan - 2014-06-26
xBTAx Wrote:Wait, wait, if I had voted TheBirds, Cakes' ability would have made them the lynch, so would have that have lynched faon too?
I... NO...
No. Cakes' first ability wouldn't have triggered because it was a MyLo situation.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - Shidoshi - 2014-06-26
Damn, two insane cops. It's fucked up that Holy didn't get a result on y0y0 when he died on the same night though. We couldn't get a clue to sanities without it.
Bleh, my instinct on CakesXD was right on Day 1 and also about Faon on Day 4. It was hard to convince with the whole LuvD / Kyra situation though. (Also CJ on Day 3).
Well played by TheBirds though.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - TheBirds - 2014-06-26
faonkarino Wrote:Oh, I had tons of fun. I believed I played a great part in leading us to victory, which makes it even more awesome.I hope to god you aren't seriously trying to take any type of credit for the mafia winning when the town was doomed from the start with its rooster and two insane cops because if so I can tell you're gonna be one of the worst new players in a while.
xBTAx Wrote:Wait, wait, if I had voted TheBirds, Cakes' ability would have made them the lynch, so would have that have lynched faon too?I got into this with ms. faon. We wouldn't have been lynched together since it says only powers hit the both of us.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - MasPan - 2014-06-26
TheBirds Wrote:I hope to god you aren't seriously trying to take any type of credit for the mafia winning when the town was doomed from the start with its rooster and two insane cops because if so I can tell you're gonna be one of the worst new players in a while. I got into this with ms. faon. We wouldn't have been lynched together since it says only powers hit the both of us.
[COLOR="#cc8899"]Not true. You WOULD have been lynched together.
Role PM Wrote:Because of your unique condition, anything that targets you or your brother will also target the other. This includes positive effects as well as negative.
A lynch is very much a targeted action. Another of the mafians asked me about this and I clarified as above.[/COLOR]
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - faonkarino - 2014-06-26
TheBirds Wrote:I hope to god you aren't seriously trying to take any type of credit for the mafia winning when the town was doomed from the start with its rooster and two insane cops because if so I can tell you're gonna be one of the worst new players in a while. I got into this with ms. faon. We wouldn't have been lynched together since it says only powers hit the both of us.
Oh, ok mate.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - Corn - 2014-06-26
TheBirds Wrote:I tried but y'all seem hell bent on dooming yourselves so good job.
Ah ha ha that was clever. I wanted to lynch you day 3 but we weren't having it.
I never accounted for 2 insane cops. That fucked me over.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - Olsi - 2014-06-26
TheBirds Wrote:I got into this with ms. faon. We wouldn't have been lynched together since it says only powers hit the both of us.It was very specifically said multiple times that the lynch does affect the both of you
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - Shidoshi - 2014-06-26
[MENTION=846]Corn[/MENTION]; could have participated more, creating a habit of not contributing much isn't really healthy to the game.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - Holypie - 2014-06-26
Yeah two insane cops was very tricky, but I think the town was pretty weak this game. No vanilla maf? Then again I guess faon/TheBirds makes up for it. Also, if I was insane shouldn't I have seen yoshi as perfectly alive and well?
Overall a really fun game though, 700 posts! That's crazy. Good job Mas!
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - Shidoshi - 2014-06-26
Holypie Wrote:Yeah two insane cops was very tricky, but I think the town was pretty weak this game. No vanilla maf? Then again I guess faon/TheBirds makes up for it. Also, if I was insane shouldn't I have seen yoshi as perfectly alive and well?
Faon and TheBirds being tied together is counterbalanced by CakesXD's lynch revenge kill.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - LuvDWayULie - 2014-06-26
Shidoshi Wrote:Faon and TheBirds being tied together is counterbalanced by CakesXD's lynch revenge kill.
True, Cakes is quite powerful IMO. I would've split the two powers and give it to another person.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - Corn - 2014-06-26
Shidoshi Wrote:Corn; could have participated more, creating a habit of not contributing much isn't really healthy to the game.
You say that as if I didn't know that was part of the problem. I don't think I can participate in the next Mafia because of time constraints.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - MasPan - 2014-06-27
LuvDWayULie Wrote:True, Cakes is quite powerful IMO. I would've split the two powers and give it to another person.
[COLOR="#cc8899"]Yeah, in retrospect I would've done that. Really the only "positive" effect that could've hit the twins would've been the doctor, so I had considered them to be almost entirely negative. The chance of losing two mafians out of five in a single blow was potentially devastating (especially considering CJ could've nabbed two extra votes by hitting them) and I wanted the mafia to have a way to tip the scales back if something happened. Cakes also wasn't aware of how his revenge kill would function exactly, so it eliminated the chance of the mafia bussing him safely.
Still, I agree - Cakes could've used a nerf, and the town could've used maybe one or two more powers (maybe a mayor).[/COLOR]
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - LuvDWayULie - 2014-06-27
MasPan Wrote:[COLOR="#cc8899"]Yeah, in retrospect I would've done that. Really the only "positive" effect that could've hit the twins would've been the doctor, so I had considered them to be almost entirely negative. The chance of losing two mafians out of five in a single blow was potentially devastating (especially considering CJ could've nabbed two extra votes by hitting them) and I wanted the mafia to have a way to tip the scales back if something happened. Cakes also wasn't aware of how his revenge kill would function exactly, so it eliminated the chance of the mafia bussing him safely.Anyway, good job, Maspan. I enjoyed the whole game
Still, I agree - Cakes could've used a nerf, and the town could've used maybe one or two more powers (maybe a mayor).[/COLOR]
The viewcount is also over 9000!!
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - Kyrastri - 2014-06-27
I'm not saying I'm bitter about the insane thing, but I'm totally bitter about the insane thing
Since TheBirds mentioned it I've been parroting that both I and Holypie may have been insane, and of course nobody even considers it during the last day >:C so much rage
I initially thought that the decision to kill me would have been pretty stupid, but I didn't forsee the faon/TheBirds pairing so that would have made sense to kill me. Good work, you two.
And Faon completely tricked me, holy guff Q n Q I was fully convinced he was a good apple... TheBirds, not so much, but far out... That was so good. I loved this game.
As promised, my investigation PMs (Role PM should be known since I died)
investigations
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - MasPan - 2014-06-27
[COLOR="#cc8899"]Note that in all of the above, I made sure to state that they were subjective. "You decide" "seems" etc. I also added the word "definitely" in the CJ one as a clue that maybe something was off, here.
It may just be my style of flavor/etc, but I tend to make things vague when I want someone to doubt that they're being told the truth or when they should feel that maybe there's information they're not getting.
Holypie's was a bit less obvious about it, but it's still there as well.
Night 2 Results Wrote:You spend a good portion of the night studying Olsi and don't see anything suspicious going on. You leave, confident that he is a good apple.[/COLOR]
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - Kyrastri - 2014-06-27
MasPan Wrote:[COLOR="#cc8899"]Note that in all of the above, I made sure to state that they were subjective. "You decide" "seems" etc. I also added the word "definitely" in the CJ one as a clue that maybe something was off, here.
It may just be my style of flavor/etc, but I tend to make things vague when I want someone to doubt that they're being told the truth or when they should feel that maybe there's information they're not getting.[/COLOR]
Ooh, that definitely makes sense in hindsight. It would have gone completely over my head, though, since this was my first game. I did post them, though, so maybe someone else could have picked it up.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - xBTAx - 2014-06-27
Oh, I don't think I ever mentioned it, but the first night I watched Cakes and nothing happened.
...my second choice would have been y0, so, great job there, past me.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - ChaoticCJ - 2014-06-27
Wow, the game turned out amazing. I like mafia games that have a good amount of abilities, it makes the game more interesting.
Looking at the roles, the game was pretty balanced; actually in all honesty it really favored the town. The real problem was the town was not always completely together in an understanding. The town kept having to bring up old topics to keep others informed on what had happened just a few hours ago. It was actually a really smart move by the mafia to keep the conversation going and flood the conversation so the real facts would be missed.
I am glad that I was right about my apple theory and Cakes. I knew something was up with Olsi, and when Kyr did turn out to be a townie-it confirmed my suspicions. I don't think I would have ever guessed TheBirds/Faonkarino. The town/mafia did a good job on building up TheBirds as some type of event they didn't want to set off.
Overall the game was really fun to play, and even watch. It was definitely one of our most active and heavy reading/thinking games. Great job MasPan.
Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory - Holypie - 2014-06-27
Oh man so we both investigated TheBirds the night we died huh. That would have been helpful. Probably could have turned the game around completely had one of us made it.