+- Southperry.net (https://www.southperry.net)
+-- Forum: Main (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=11)
+--- Forum: Site Announcements (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=18)
+--- Thread: Southperry Logo Contest Voting! (/showthread.php?tid=58353)
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - ShinkuDragon - 2012-10-17
yea, i meant it outlined.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Raul - 2012-10-17
1. Looks shitty small.
2. Also looks shitty small, and I don't like the outline.
3. Can't read the SP, black outline looks shitty.
4. Looks gaudy and focuses too much on one aspect of the site.
5. I like this one. A lot. It somehow manages to work at all sizes without being overly simplistic.
6. Too small, hate the color, outline of the thing looks shitty.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Rick - 2012-10-17
Why do people like number 5. What attachment does Southperry have to anchors?
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Spaz - 2012-10-17
Only #3 and #2 don't look terrible at favicon size.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Ampule - 2012-10-17
I think this should be narrowed down even more, to the obvious front-runners. Let the people who voted for 2, 4, and 6 recast their opinion.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Alloy - 2012-10-17
Rick Wrote:Why do people like number 5. What attachment does Southperry have to anchors?
Time to blow your minds. Go to southperry ingame. Check the map icon.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Panacea - 2012-10-17
Alloy Wrote:Time to blow your minds. Go to southperry ingame. Check the map icon.
Still think it looks ridiculous.
To each their own.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Zerard - 2012-10-17
Also, am I the only one noticing that #3 is essentially our current favicon with 'SP' at the top left?
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Dudewitbow - 2012-10-17
3 is my personal choice, followed by 1, then 5.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Loose - 2012-10-17
Raul Wrote:3. Can't read the SP, black outline looks shitty.There's no black on number 3.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - TaliaNCo - 2012-10-17
Locked Wrote:In order #1-6 in Chrome.
In case anyone else was curious.
Thank you for doing that. I certainly was curious, as I think that the logo needs more color to stand out a bit more. The lighter colors just don't seem to do it any justice otherwise.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Eos - 2012-10-17
TaliaNCo Wrote:Thank you for doing that. I certainly was curious
It's important to remember though that the browser icon isn't the only place this will represent us.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - TaliaNCo - 2012-10-17
Eos Wrote:It's important to remember though that the browser icon isn't the only place this will represent us.
I realize that. I just think the color needs to be a little darker if the nimble feet was going to partially stay. Having a bit more defined lines would make it stand out more no matter where it is.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Raul - 2012-10-17
Loose Wrote:There's no black on number 3.
There's definitely a black outline to the icon itself.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Eos - 2012-10-17
Raul Wrote:There's definitely a black outline to the icon itself.
His point is it's purple, not black.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Locked - 2012-10-17
Rick Wrote:Why do people like number 5. What attachment does Southperry have to anchors?
It's the only one in my opinion that doesn't look horrible at a small size. Plus it's.. different, I guess.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Felicitates - 2012-10-17
Tbh, these are all incredibly uncreative except for #4 & #5.
I would vote for the extractor except that it wouldn't match the site. It has a clever meaning, but its color should try to stay within the blue in my opinion.
I voted for the anchor simply because its something new, although again, the artist should have shaded the S =\
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - byakugan - 2012-10-17
I had no idea southperry has an Icon somewhere. What a newb.
Rick Wrote:Why do people like number 5. What attachment does Southperry have to anchors?
-Southperry's ingame icon is an anchor
-Actual name was SouthFerry based on the ship taking passagers from MapleIsland to Victoria.
-What relationship feathers have with Southperry whatsoever? Even the extractor makes more sense.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - Raul - 2012-10-17
Eos Wrote:His point is it's purple, not black.
Okaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay then.
My point still stands about it looking like pomegranate.
Southperry Logo Contest Voting! - TaliaNCo - 2012-10-17
Felicitates Wrote:Tbh, these are all incredibly uncreative except for #4 & #5.
I would vote for the extractor except that it wouldn't match the site. It has a clever meaning, but its color should try to stay within the blue in my opinion.
I voted for the anchor simply because its something new, although again, the artist should have shaded the S =\
I actually said the same thing about the extractor when we were voting in the moderator forum. Love the idea behind it, but thought the color scheme should've matched the site better.
ETA: On a completely different note, I'm glad to see so many people voting on this.
