Southperry.net
Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Printable Version

+- Southperry.net (https://www.southperry.net)
+-- Forum: Main (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=11)
+--- Forum: Site Announcements (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=18)
+--- Thread: Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! (/showthread.php?tid=34833)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - thinbear - 2010-12-21

Is it logo or banner?

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Rob - 2010-12-21

thinbear Wrote:Is it logo or banner?

Banner.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Pixie - 2010-12-21

Rob Wrote:
Fiel Wrote:Didn't like 7

It's too loud and it doesn't flow with the page.
It's kinda aggressive, that's true. Problem is that the lines are... too thick.

btw, no prize for the one who came up with the idea :<


<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<



I had originally planned to submit something like number 7, but when I tried to fix the border it was a little fuzzy & choppy, so I think that's why the designer made the border thick. But anyways, the ones I made still didn't make it haha. I guess it was just too much going on or too colorful ;(

Good job on the banners. The idea of number 1 is cute, but I voted for 6. Are we able to see all of the entries?

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Russt - 2010-12-21

For those of you who want to preview the submissions in current context and don't care to do it yourself:
(apologies for the resized image quality, and keep in mind that spacing is dependent on the image files given and can be adjusted if admin feels it necessary)

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8


Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Rob - 2010-12-21

Can we change votes? ;_;

In context some of them look so much better.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Stereo - 2010-12-21

I went back and forth between 3 and 6 but ultimately I chose 3.

Too bad it can never win.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Sarah - 2010-12-21

Argh. Kind of want to change my vote now. #7 is the best stand-alone image but it looks out of place. #6 fits really well and looks nice.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Rob - 2010-12-21

Sarah Wrote:Argh. Kind of want to change my vote now. #7 is the best stand-alone image but it looks out of place. #6 fits really well and looks nice.

THIS OH SO MUCH THIS.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Rick - 2010-12-21

2-6 are the only ones that truly look like they're not out of place, but 2-5 are far too plain and I don't like the text on 6. 7 is nice but doesn't fit in context, 8 just looks like an amateur Basil banner and 1 is the best style for Southperry, but it just doesn't seem to fit right. Ultimately and unfortunately, I'd go with 6.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Corn - 2010-12-21

Huh, 7 looks better than I thought. 4 looks crappy now.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - HighOnMushrooms - 2010-12-21

Sarah Wrote:Argh. Kind of want to change my vote now. #7 is the best stand-alone image but it looks out of place. #6 fits really well and looks nice.

I agree xP

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Eos - 2010-12-21

Pixie Wrote:Are we able to see all of the entries?

Not until after the voting concludes. Don't want distractions or whining about who/what should've been included.

Rob Wrote:
Sarah Wrote:Argh. Kind of want to change my vote now. #7 is the best stand-alone image but it looks out of place. #6 fits really well and looks nice.

THIS OH SO MUCH THIS.

We can always reset the votes.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Sn1perJohnE - 2010-12-21

Russt Wrote:For those of you who want to preview the submissions in current context and don't care to do it yourself:
(apologies for the resized image quality, and keep in mind that spacing is dependent on the image files given and can be adjusted if admin feels it necessary)

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8

Given these, 6 fits best, 7 would work too, but there would need to be some dithering added here and there.

8....Ill be damned if I see a basilmarket-esque banner on mah southperry.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - TaliaNCo - 2010-12-21

Eosian Wrote:Not until after the voting concludes. Don't want distractions or whining about who/what should've been included.



We can always reset the votes.

Not a bad idea Eos since we are ahead of my original timeline. The way Russt did them, it does give a different perspective. I'll keep this is mind for any future related contests. Will have to reset when I get home unless you'd like to do it for me. ;P

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Zelkova - 2010-12-21

I voted for 7. Since I am the lord of sp, my choice will win.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Eos - 2010-12-21

TaliaNCo Wrote:Will have to reset when I get home unless you'd like to do it for me. ;P

Think I'm the only one who can.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - Russt - 2010-12-21

Sorry.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - FelixTM - 2010-12-21

#3 is the best, but it's not better than our current. If we have to change, I'd go with #3.

1 is stupid, 8 is absolutely horrendous. 2, 4, 5 and 6 are unfitting, ugly or not good enough. 7 is overrated in its current state. It is the best overall image, but it needs work if it's going to be our banner. Doesn't fit near well enough as is.

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - thinbear - 2010-12-21

just realized last one is one piece >_>

Vote for your favorite Southperry banner!!! - TaliaNCo - 2010-12-21

Russt Wrote:Sorry.

Don't be sorry. What you did really gave me a new perspective and I'm sure it did the same for others too. It was a good idea Russt. Smile