+- Southperry.net (https://www.southperry.net)
+-- Forum: Social (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=14)
+--- Forum: Rubik's Cube (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=58)
+--- Thread: Cleaning the Gene Pool (/showthread.php?tid=23011)
Pages:
1
2
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Russt - 2010-02-27
Cyadd Wrote:shipped off to Africa.
Deportment, then. Isolation from the outside.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trail_of_Tears
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_American_internment
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Lyssa - 2010-02-27
There's a lot of good points being brought up against this idea.
The first comparison that came to my mind is Hitler. This idea doesn't directly kill the people, but it certainly could be condemning them to die sooner, rather than later. That's not really fair, is it? It's discrimination of an incredibly high level.
Genetically "perfect" people can be completely useless jackasses, and genetically "impure" people can contribute much to society. If you go by pure scientifics, you might get away with the idea. But there's a moral aspect too. It's not right to condemn people because they've had the misfortune to be born a certain way or to contract a specific disease.
~Lyssa
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Heidi - 2010-02-27
Lucida Wrote:And Heidi, STDs by definition aren't genetic.
I know they aren't
Blame the thread starter for the title, not me
Though I do see your point. But that's just STD's, NOTHING to do with genetic disorders like the thread was for.
Cleaning the Gene Pool - y0y0y0y0shi0 - 2010-02-27
Cyadd Wrote:[COLOR="red"]No.
I took it in the sense that Africa doens't have natural resources and land to farm on as say, America. There would be less and less food. Kids die everyday from a lack of food, is it genocide?[/COLOR]
Genocide is generally defined as the intentional/planned mass murder of people.
Is kids dieing from a lack of food intentional? No. Is it planned? No.
Is sending people to a completely secluded area intentional? Yes. Is them dieing planned? Yes.
Cleaning the Gene Pool - RideBMX - 2010-02-27
Make AIDS go away?
Humans cannot stop popping out babies, so keep them in check with all these diseases.
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Swerve - 2010-02-27
This thread is retarded. Scientifically speaking of course.
1. Inbreeding leads to genetic diseases. I.e. Wikipedia Amish people and then search for: genetic disorders. Isolating a 1% population that has supposedly "perfect" genes will lead to inbreeding. Especially if you continue to route off "imperfections" to Africa.
2. There is no such thing as perfect genomes. Genomes are holistic compositions of individual genes. African Americans have a gene for tubular shaped hair making them 90% less likely to have lice grown in their hair compared to caucasians and other races. But they also are 90% more likely to have genes for sickle-cell anemia. A trait in which red blood cells are shaped like sickles and restrict blow flow in the human body.
3. This thread is retarded because there is a reason why 90% of all organisms within a species mate and produce heterzygous offspring instead of homozygotes. It's because it works. I have a thousand more examples I could pull out of my ass. But I don't think anyone is interested in actually learning anything regardless of how "cool" I make it. So I'll just leave it at this.
The result: the imperfect people will live healthier in Africa than the perfect people who will probably have Huntington's Disease and Downsyndrome. Poor perfect people.
Cleaning the Gene Pool - DeanNim - 2010-02-28
PEople with STDs including HIV should be jailed for having sex. Jews should beheaded. thats enough.
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Derimed - 2010-02-28
ugh not worth it
Cleaning the Gene Pool - ablu2 - 2010-03-29
1: Holocaust redo.
2: Why dont we get rid of everyone with allergies, everyone who has less then a 5.0 grade average, everyone who is ugly, everyone who is of a certain religion,and everyone who doesnt like chinese food while were at it?
3: Idea sucks. Sorry, but its the truth.
Cleaning the Gene Pool - FelixTM - 2010-03-29
Would be much cooler to gather all the NEETs and give us our own massive area to live. It could be awesome losers + hobos land.
Haha, awesome.
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Spideyjvc - 2010-03-29
Swerve Wrote:This thread is retarded. Scientifically speaking of course.
1. Inbreeding leads to genetic diseases. I.e. Wikipedia Amish people and then search for: genetic disorders. Isolating a 1% population that has supposedly "perfect" genes will lead to inbreeding. Especially if you continue to route off "imperfections" to Africa.
2. There is no such thing as perfect genomes. Genomes are holistic compositions of individual genes. African Americans have a gene for tubular shaped hair making them 90% less likely to have lice grown in their hair compared to caucasians and other races. But they also are 90% more likely to have genes for sickle-cell anemia. A trait in which red blood cells are shaped like sickles and restrict blow flow in the human body.
3. This thread is retarded because there is a reason why 90% of all organisms within a species mate and produce heterzygous offspring instead of homozygotes. It's because it works. I have a thousand more examples I could pull out of my ass. But I don't think anyone is interested in actually learning anything regardless of how "cool" I make it. So I'll just leave it at this.
The result: the imperfect people will live healthier in Africa than the perfect people who will probably have Huntington's Disease and Downsyndrome. Poor perfect people.
Yeah, this kinda covers it. You can't "get rid" of this stuff. There will always be some illness that will pop up, and there will always be genetic defects. It's impossible, the idea wouldn't work out at all.
FelixTM Wrote:Would be much cooler to gather all the NEETs and give us our own massive area to live. It could be awesome losers + hobos land.
Haha, awesome.
Haha
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Locked - 2010-03-29
ablu2 Wrote:1: Holocaust redo.
2: Why dont we get rid of everyone with allergies, everyone who has less then a 5.0 grade average, everyone who is ugly, everyone who is of a certain religion,and everyone who doesnt like chinese food while were at it?
3: Idea sucks. Sorry, but its the truth.
This post got a warning?
I don't like the TS' idea anyway.
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Shidoshi - 2010-03-29
Another problem with your idea would be that the "errors" could just as well create their own society and not just "die off" since they would be lots of people. You would have a world divided in two parts that hate each other and both with equal conditions.
WAR, yay!
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Cancambo - 2010-03-29
2147483647 Wrote:The TS sounds like this:
[spoiler=][/spoiler]
No offense.
Is it bad that I totally agreed with what he was saying? It sounds so much better than what actually happened.
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Felicitates - 2010-03-30
[COLOR="Magenta"]This reminds me of:
http://www.thevenusproject.com/
P.S. There is fertile land in Africa. Its not all just desert.
[/COLOR]
![[Image: 534px-Africa_satellite_orthographic.jpg]](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/21/Africa_satellite_orthographic.jpg/534px-Africa_satellite_orthographic.jpg)
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Swerve - 2010-03-30
There are also industrialized cities and five-star hotels that trump Holiday Inn any day of the week. Thanks for the heads up. I thought they were just a bunch of rural savages.
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Heidi - 2010-03-30
Locked Wrote:This post got a warning?
I don't like the TS' idea anyway.
It was a necro post though
Cleaning the Gene Pool - MasPan - 2010-03-30
Wouldn't it be easier to just surgically prevent them from having children?
Cleaning the Gene Pool - Nikkey - 2010-03-30
Locked Wrote:This post got a warning?
I don't like the TS' idea anyway.
Necropost.