ElectricSix Wrote:Hmm, if Dusk isn't Zerg, I don't think he's likely to be Protoss either.I base that on the fact that he voted y0shi back on Day 1, and while that might be a decent tactic to hide being mafia, it seems rather dangerous as people could have easily picked y0shi that day instead of Kajiti and ran with it. I think that means he's likely a Neutral. I could be wrong, but that's just my two cents.

As for Hiep, no posts, but nothing stating he's been idle, likewise for Synthesist. Thus I think one of them is likely a Zerg mafia member, the other likely a Terran/Neutral based purely on odds and guessing. Since it'd make sense in a funny kind of way for there to be three lurkers and each one being of a different race. Though again, mostly guessing about that.

ChaoticCJ Wrote:ITT: Almost everyone has talked after they died.

ElectricSix Wrote:Hmm, if Dusk isn't Zerg, I don't think he's likely to be Protoss either.I base that on the fact that he voted y0shi back on Day 1, and while that might be a decent tactic to hide being mafia, it seems rather dangerous as people could have easily picked y0shi that day instead of Kajiti and ran with it. I think that means he's likely a Neutral. I could be wrong, but that's just my two cents.

As for Hiep, no posts, but nothing stating he's been idle, likewise for Synthesist. Thus I think one of them is likely a Zerg mafia member, the other likely a Terran/Neutral based purely on odds and guessing. Since it'd make sense in a funny kind of way for there to be three lurkers and each one being of a different race. Though again, mostly guessing about that.

Mephisto Wrote:No, seriously, you're an idiot if you still think that what I said doesn't make sense.

ElectricSix Wrote:So I decided to go through the list and weed out people to determine the likely Zerg/Protoss mafia members.

 Spoiler

Possible Protoss: (Approximated 1-2 are mafia)
Synthesist - As HolyPie said, he always seems to be lurking, so he could be anything.
ThatHurts - One of the few remaining people not affected by any Protoss moves
xBTAx - Probably a Terran based upon his statement after Kajiti was lynched, but I don't want to just assume that on the offchance one of the lurkers was in fact that person instead, and for whatever reason, they have chosen not to reveal themselves.
Hiepocrite - Another lurker/non poster, anything but Zerg at this point.
ChaoticCJ - One of the few remaining people not affected by any Protoss moves, leaves them highly suspect.

Possible Zerg: (Approximated 2-3 are mafia)
ElectricSix: Yes I included myself, to be fair. I had a vortex move used on me, therefore 50/50 Zerg, Terran.
ClawofBeta: Stasis move used on, therefore 50/50 Zerg, Terran.
DualReaver: Stasis move used on, therefore 50/50 Zerg, Terran.
Ray/Darkmaniak: Stasis move used on, therefore 50/50 Zerg, Terran.
Synthesist - Refer to my previous statement.
ThatHurts: One of the few remaining people not affected by any Protoss moves, could be due to immunity/night action.
xBTAx: Refer to my previous statement.
MasPan: Vortex move used on, therefore 50/50 Zerg, Terran.
ChaoticCJ: One of the few remaining people not affected by any Protoss moves, could be due to immunity/night action.

My thoughts on the Possible Zerg:
ElectricSix: I'm not a Zerg, but I included my name as before.
DualReaver: I don't think he's a mafian, but so far, there's been no proof to convince me other than my gut feeling.
Ray/Darkmaniak: Possible, though if that's the case, it would seem to suggest MasPan isn't.
Synthesist: Stays on the list due to his lurking.
ThatHurts: Most likely a Protoss given everything, but it's still possible they're Zerg.
xBTAx: Stays on the list for the same reasons as before.
MasPan: Most likely a Terran, but if he is, that would seem to imply Ray isn't.
ChaoticCJ: Most likely a Protoss given everything, but it's still possible they're Zerg.

Fairly confirmed Terrans imo:
ClawofBeta - Probably a Terran given everything, but still possible that they're neutral given his roleclaim.
Kurtle - Almost 100% Terran, but slime possibility that they're neutral.

Fairly likely Neutral:
Dusk - Given my previous reasons, I suspect he's a neutral, though again, this is mostly guesswork.

Confirmed Terran:
TobiasBlack - Pretty much proved it with his success on Meta.

Though I may have to revise my opinion based upon tonights results, I'd say that my top mafia picks atm are as follows: Synthesist, ThatHurts, and ChaoticCJ. All three of them appear on both of my lists. Should any of them be votexed or stasised, then obviously they remain possible Zerg, but get moved off my Protoss list. Assuming nothing changes, I'll likely vote Synthesist, but ThatHurts and ChaoticCJ remain fairly high on my list unless someone vouches for them; i.e. Kurtle and/or Tobias.

MetaSeraphim Wrote:Do you like putting words into my mouth or something? I never once said what you said didn't make sense.

MetaSeraphim Wrote:How do you know they have two powerful roles when only one Protoss has been killed and your skill only allows you to detect the bio-signature of a player? Seems pretty off to me.

If you can provide a good reason for how you know they have two powerful roles I'll remove my vote,

MetaSeraphim Wrote:And that I voted for you because of your odd statement which has yet to be proven.

ElectricSix Wrote:Stasis sucks, but no deaths right? That's excellent. For me, I'm gonna [vote] Synthesist unless someone else has a better idea.

Dusk Wrote:Mephisto and Meta, can you stop posting? You're both dead. I can understand a non-game related clarification post or two, but goddamn.