+- Southperry.net (https://www.southperry.net)
+-- Forum: Social (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=14)
+--- Forum: Forum Games & Unofficial Activities/Events (https://www.southperry.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=56)
+--- Thread: Bad Apple Mafia Discussion (/showthread.php?tid=71363)
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - Shidoshi - 2014-06-24
Let's stop discussing the game after you've died?
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - LuvDWayULie - 2014-06-24
Shidoshi Wrote:Let's stop discussing the game after you've died?
Okay, ex-boss. *Haunts Shidoshi*
WoooooooOOOOooo..
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - Kyrastri - 2014-06-25
woooOOooOOOoooooooOooo sorry Shidoshi, if I said anything out of line tell me so I can get it edited out oooooOOooOOoooooooOOOOoooOoO
damn haunting people is fun
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - LuvDWayULie - 2014-06-25
Kyrastri Wrote:woooOOooOOOoooooooOooo sorry Shidoshi, if I said anything out of line tell me so I can get it edited out oooooOOooOOoooooooOOOOoooOoO
damn haunting people is fun
Wooooooooooooo, it is!
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - MasPan - 2014-06-25
I'll detail some of the less obvious events that happened once the game is over, of course.
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - LuvDWayULie - 2014-06-25
MasPan Wrote:I'll detail some of the less obvious events that happened once the game is over, of course.
Thanks, boss
Wooo to you.
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - Holypie - 2014-06-25
Yeah okay since I don't know where else to post this (sorry Mas) I think I'll host a Game of Thrones/Song of Ice and Fire mafia after Niernen's Pokemon mafia. Yay, so much mafia.
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - MasPan - 2014-06-25
Holypie Wrote:Yeah okay since I don't know where else to post this (sorry Mas) I think I'll host a Game of Thrones/Song of Ice and Fire mafia after Niernen's Pokemon mafia. Yay, so much mafia.
It's cool. Count me in. Are you planning on using material/characters from all the way through book 5, or just up to where the show is currently, or ?
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - Holypie - 2014-06-25
I'm going to set it at the battle for the Wall as to avoid major book spoilers. Also I think that's a pretty fun setting, lots of interesting characters up there.
Actually Meereen would make a really good setting too, with the Harpies and all that. Also King's Landing, with all the politics.
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - MasPan - 2014-06-25
Holypie Wrote:I'm going to set it at the battle for the Wall as to avoid major book spoilers. Also I think that's a pretty fun setting, lots of interesting characters up there.
Actually Meereen would make a really good setting too, with the Harpies and all that. Also King's Landing, with all the politics.
King's Landing would probably be the best setting imo. The Wall has a lot of memorable characters, but King's Landing has a lot more easily-recognized ones.
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - Shidoshi - 2014-06-25
That looks like a really fun flavor to base a mafia game. I'll be looking forward to it.
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - LuvDWayULie - 2014-06-25
Wooooo, I shall resurrect from the grave and take on a Pokemon form then.. WOOOOOOOOO..
On another note, the game thread looks like it's dying... I missed the more active times
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - Holypie - 2014-06-25
MasPan Wrote:King's Landing would probably be the best setting imo. The Wall has a lot of memorable characters, but King's Landing has a lot more easily-recognized ones.
I might do another one with King's Landing later, when the show gets there. Lots more fun stuff to come
But yeah I think the one I have for the Wall will be pretty interesting.
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - Liable - 2014-06-25
I may join in one of the upcoming mafia games (except I live in Australia like kyrastri, so I'm not sure how that'll work for me). I've started following the Two Island game briefly and been extensively reading this current game. Making my own analysis and whatnot and learning some of these jargons and how it's been played, has been really exciting.
Looking forward to the finale
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - xBTAx - 2014-06-25
I really need to get to work on mine, since I wasn't as free as I expected last weekend; I can definitely have it ready in the next few days but I just need to sit down and work some things out. I'd say to expect signups a day or two after this one ends.
I'd definitely be into a GoT/ASOIAF game. I second what Mas said, though, especially as the Wall's characters barely count as named characters for show watchers, so getting stuck with a more minor character will be that much less fun if you don't even recognize them.
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - Holypie - 2014-06-25
Fair points, but the battle for the Wall has such good flavour stuff that I can do though. I admit that some characters are probably unrecognizable (or omitted altogether) from the show but I think the game will be fun (and I've written a lot for it and I don't want to start over[that's the main reason]).
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - Kyrastri - 2014-06-26
Looking forward to the Pokemon mafia, though I don't know enough about GoT so I'll probably be left in the dark c:
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - LuvDWayULie - 2014-06-26
Kyrastri Wrote:Looking forward to the Pokemon mafia, though I don't know enough about GoT so I'll probably be left in the dark c:I'll do both . Haven't watched GoT but will understand it by then.
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - y0y0y0y0shi0 - 2014-06-26
Major notes:
Outing yourself as a cop to "save" one person because you had a supposedly innocent town result on them = terrrrriiiibbbbllllleeee. Very easily manipulable, and not guaranteed sanities.
I can understand not wanting to lynch CJ because of the chance mafia was killing me to frame him, which incidentally was the case, but that was extremely scummy play regardless and should've been looked into more than half the day and 2 minutes of "oh someone claimed cop on them they must be town."
Imagine of Kyrastri had been scum with CJ. They both would've gotten off scot-free that day.
SOMETIMES it's better to pay more attention to someone's behaviors rather than what they say. There were quite a few posts that were just completely out of place in the thread and should've raised red flags, but were ignored for the longer more meaningless posts. It mostly involved people saying things without actually saying anything; mindless filler.
People were paying too much attention to each others' accusations and such without looking at the rest of it.
And don't get too emotionally/personally involved in this game. It's a game. No point getting hung up on it. No point treating each other poorly because of it.
And please for the love of god don't post in the discussion thread if you're commenting on the game, especially if you're alive. 90% of posts in this thread are just cringeworthy. I could pretty much tell you exactly who is town just from looking at this thread.
I know it's pomegranatety to do so but if it continues we might need to be stricter on it. Modkills for it might have to be more heavily used.
Edit: Don't listen to me 100% of the time. Mafia's a very opinionated game. Use your judgment. If you have mafia results on someone, you can still try and get them lynched without outing yourself as a cop. Subtlety can be a good thing. If you don't have to do something, don't do it. Chances are you can convince people of lynching someone without the need for role information.
And, at that, don't always listen to role information. Never rely on it. Scumhunting is often a much more effective tool than trying to game the setup with role information.
Bad Apple Mafia Discussion - Olsi - 2014-06-26
I even posted once quoting maspan's saying that it was frowned upon to post reactions and people still did it
.All in all good game guys, it was tough for the town i think.
But Rekt